Updated for:
Thursday, February 09, 2012 6:24 PM
Subscribe to:
Published On:Friday, September 25, 2009
By TANEKA
HOMPSON
Tribune Staff Reporter
tthompson@tribunemedia.net
A LEADER in the private banking system has decided to withdraw from the Bahamas before the end of the year because this country has failed to escape the powerful OECD's "grey-list" of so-called tax havens.
French-based bank BNP Paribas (Bahamas) Limited -- which operates in more than 80 countries -- said despite "excellent" financial performance in the current economic crisis it had to review its network "in the context of the ongoing changes in the world financial system and G20 initiatives."
"In the light of this review, BNP Paribas has taken the decision to withdraw before the end of 2010 from countries grey listed by the OECD and viewed as Tax Havens. This includes the Bahamas," said a brief statement released by the company yesterday.
The bank said it will try its best to maintain its clients' interests, but the fate of the 40 persons employed there is uncertain.
According to a well-placed source, BNP's move is "a political one", in line with French President Nicholas Sarkozy's views.
"It's definitely political -- they don't want to be seen in grey or black-listed places," said the source, who believes other private banks may follow BNP's lead.
When contacted for comment yesterday, State Finance Minister Zhirvargo Laing said while the bank's decision was "regrettable" the Bahamas was working feverishly to meet the OECD's minimum requirements by the end of the year.
"It's a regrettable decision to the extent that you don't want to see a reputable bank like Paribas leaving. It has significant implications for their staff and their clients and there's also the tendency to have the jurisdiction lose a valuable presence. But again this is one of the reasons why we are working as feverishly as we have been to meet the (OECD's) standards.
"We know there might be those entities that will find it difficult to remain (here), if the Bahamas remains in the grey list. We fully expect to meet that standard by the end of the year but that does not mean we cannot meet it sooner," he said.
The OECD requires 12 tax information exchange agreements (TIEA) as a minimum requirement to be "white-listed." Mr Laing said the Bahamas has signed three -- one with the United States, one with Monaco, and the latest signed yesterday with San Morino.
The news came the same day the powerful G-20 leaders met in Pittsburgh to discuss, among other things, ways to crack down on tax havens. The group was expected to assess the progress of off-shore jurisdictions that had not met the OECD's white list requirements.
International reports state that French President Nicolas Sarkozy is urging his G20 counterparts to agree to impose sanctions on uncooperative tax havens as early as 2010. Meantime, Pascal Dulau, CEO of BNP Paribas (Bahamas) Ltd said there is no firm date when the bank will pull its services out of the country.
"We don't close, we are exiting meaning that we are trying to find a solution by trying to sell or transfer the business depending on the clients -- but there is no official date where we say we turn out the lights. We will withdraw from the Bahamas but will take the necessary (steps)."
When asked if the bank would reconsider its position if the Bahamas managed to make it onto the OECD's white-list before the end of the year, Mr Dulau said: "Once you take this decision you can't go back."
The Bahamas was placed on the OECD's grey list, part of a naming and shaming of so-called tax havens by the G20 nations, in April.
Posted By: Boo Ya On: 3/1/2010
Title: one small idea in the right direction
as I've mentioned before; the U.S. and other super powers spend huge money to incarcerate their prisoners. Perfect irony would be for the big countries to pay us to build prisons and watch over their bad guys. I believe they'd pay, with the proper negotiating, for us to build a prison and then house the world's terrorsists. Do it in the middle of Andros. There's already a U.S. Military presence there and none of us want to go live in the buggy swamps. Huge potential for a prisoner warehousing industry. Probably employ hundreds to build and staff, not to mention develop Andros! We could move Fox Hill Prison there as well and have the U.S. pay for it!!!!
Posted By: Dr. Dexter Reno JOhnson On: 2/27/2010
Title: End of living off pure service industries
The differential tax advantage that the Bahamas enjoyed is at an end due to the actions of the G2o countries led by President Obama and Prime Minister Gordon Brown. The writing is on the wall...countries like the Bahamas will loose 15% of GDP formerly obtained as the direct or indirect result of their differential tax status and their bank secrecy laws.
Unless we are sensible and diversify our economy into agro/fisheries we will fail to replace this shortfall in our national earnings, and suffer a fall in our life style.
Tourism has been in decline since 2005, so welcome to the Post-Tourism era...the period when earnings from tourism will not be able to sustain the current Bahamian lifestyle for so many persons. The divide into a small ruling class living off the biggest slice of tourism revenue, and a much larger lower class of persons condemned to living off the crumbs from the tourism table has begun. We should have diversified our economy since 1973, and it is proof of consistently poor leadership at the highest level that we find ourselves in this dire predicament...You cannot rely on leaders committed to a purely service industry economy to provide for our long term survival and sustainability.
Posted By: Soverienty On: 2/15/2010
Title: BNP leaves Bah
To Andron,
"Tax havens are wrong in every sense"...This is what we let them label us, but it is far from the truth! Any citizen who pay their taxes annually, and its verifiable, has the right to place whats left for them, whereever they please. Why dont you talk about the greed of the Government IRS, for example and all the tax greedy collectors, who go after every single dollar a person works so hard for. Its call nest egg, putting aside something for hard times. Capital gains tax, what about that, why does the government just take and take, that is why the average person will never be able to have a roof over their heads! Everything is out of reach, because folks salaries never go up, or keep in line with inflation..where is the fairness. What Americans and all the tax jurisdictions need to do is put pressure on its governments to stop raping them of their had earned dollars. Stop labelling places like Bahamas as Tax havens.....After I pay my taxes, its my business what I do with the rest of my money...the people that have the power in their hands, have allowed the governments to dictate, is that democracy at work, NO IT IS NOT. CUBA treats its people better! There is no democracy in the USA, its dictatorship! The Bahamas and Switzerland, and all other tax free jurisdictions needs to protect themselves, and stand up against this g7, oecd nonsense!
Posted By: Valentine On: 1/30/2010
Title: BNP Paribas Departure
Perhaps, we may consider the conceived officious dispaly of money when we attend Governmental, International conferences, i.e. 'aides', TV crew, driver, Butler, Confidante, et al. Question arises (from one of my Banking associates) regarding the affordability of the display by the Bahamas contingent vs the other attendees i.e. G7 or G20 countries. These countries also are aware of the business generated by Banks such as BNP Paribas and their locations. Where does the business come from, i.e. the Bahamas economy?
Posted By: Andron Evans On: 12/14/2009
Title: God at work
Neither FNM or PLP can do anything. The Bahamas is populated by evil minded, corrupt, morally bankrupt sinners. From the heads of government down to the bums on the street. We, for decades, chased the American dream of wealth and prosperity, meanwhile strampling on and neglecting our poor. We love money way too much. Tax havens are wrong in every sense. In other words, we are protecting people who are stealing form their own gorvernment. Why or how could that ever be considered right or acceptable. We have embraced Americanism, greedy capitalism, sinful worldly values and endeavors. What exactly did we expect to happen after decades of acting like we do? It's just too bad that innocent persons will suffer the lot of the majority, but I guess now we will all know just how poor poor can really be.
Posted By: Elgatha On: 11/21/2009
Title: Jesus Christ
Between the thugs robbing tourists and this, the Bahamas is about to if not already, be brought to its knees. Come on FNM do something.
Posted By: Derek On: 11/18/2009
Title: C.O.R.E
This is obviously a clear-cut situation where the Government should remove red-tape beauracracy and step up this initiative to sign more treaties if it is serious.
Their method should be to "deputize" key financial figures to seek, identify, research, formulate and secure jurisdictions in which to join. The actual ceremonious signing of these treaties is only a formality for the Minister. He is no more knowledgeable than those in the financial communities and only authorized to sign because of his post in the Government.
The appointment of these "TIEA" committies should come forthwith and then the Government could delegate intiatives. My grandmother used to say that "Plenty Hands make light work". Get Crackin' govt before you exacerbate this recession.
Posted By: Stanley Jackson Sr. On: 10/24/2009
Title: Diversify The Bahamas
Unfortunately the Bahamas will be greatly negativley affected by this banks departure and any others that leave our shores. The Bahamas needs to seriously consider diversifying its base by adding more value to the tourisim product. One way to acheive this would be to look at Panama's duty free shopping zone and using the Freeport trans-shipping terminal turn the Bahamas into a duty free shopping distination simular to Panama. Agriculture is another avenue for exploitation. We must stop the procrastination in Government and force sensible sustainable moves with-in the economy.
Posted By: Concerned Citizen On: 9/25/2009
Title: The Government needs to be accountable
The Government of the Bahamas' stagnation to effectively react, especially in comparison to other jurisdictions with financial services as a major industry, is very disheartening, especially given the economic climate that we are currently facing. Tourism, our number one industry is suffering and now our Private Banking sector is being threatened because those who are in the position to make the necessary changes to save such a major Industry as our Financial Services Industry are not being proactive. More financial services bodies such as AIBT and BFSB need to express views on this issue to move the government towards accountability for the citizens of The Bahamas who are employed in these sectors. This has the potential to have a domino effect and lord help us then because unemployment will skyrocket.
To view this site, you need to have Flash Player 8.0 or later installed. Click here to get the latest Flash player.