$200m resort opponent hits planning ‘disgrace’

By NEIL HARTNELL 

Tribune Business Editor

nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

The $200m Rosewood Exuma resort’s key opponent is slamming as “a disgrace” the decision by Bahamian planning authorities to accept - and grant their approval - based on an application that did not set-out the project’s full scope and impact.

Turtlegrass Resort & Island Club, in the October 13, 2026, closing submissions supporting its bid to overturn the neighbouring development’s preliminary site plan approval, is alleging that the Town Planning Committee’s original go-ahead did not take into account important aspects of the project because they were not covered in the original application.

However, Yntegra Group, the Miami-based developer behind the Rosewood Exuma development, is arguing in its opposing submissions that the Subdivision Development and Appeal Board should have “no hesitation” in dismissing the latest challenge by Turtlegrass on the basis that it has dropped its own, rival eco-resort development.

Yntegra and its attorneys, Delaney Partners, have seized on purported admissions by Jeffrey Clark, the Turtlegrass chief financial officer, during the Appeal Board’s September 2026 hearings that its principal, Bob Coughlin, had “decided not to pursue the eco-tourism resort” as removing any grounds its neighbour has for opposing the Rosewood Exuma development.

And, noting that the Department of Environmental Planning and Protection (DEPP) had already granted it the necessary certificate of environmental clearance (CEC), Yntegra is asserting: “Turtlegrass’ environmental concerns should not be a basis for setting aside and/or varying the decision of the Town Planning Committee to grant preliminary approval.

“Furthermore, given Turtlegrass’ decision that it will no longer pursue a resort development, which was the entire basis of its opposition, the Appeal Board should have no hesitation in dismissing this appeal based on the concession by Mr Clark.” However, Mr Coughlin and Turtlegrass have previously asserted that they have not abandoned their eco-resort plan, but merely put it on hold due to the uncertainties created by Yntegra’s project.

They assert that the arguments from the Rosewood Exuma developer ignore both ‘cause’ in terms of its development ambitions and ‘effect’ in the pause that Mr Coughlin has made until the battle over the location of Yntegra’s service dock and seawall, and their impact on Sampson Cay’s North Bay, is resolved.

The Miami-based developer, urging the Appeal Board to uphold its preliminary site plan approval, added: “There is no opposition to the development on the ground that the area is not appropriate for use as a resort. That is conceded by both the appellant, Sampson Cay Retreat, the operator of Turtlegrass resort, and the other objector, Yonder Holdings, which both own and operate resorts on or adjacent to Sampson Cay.

“The proposed development by the developer is also capable of co-existing with the proposed development by Turtlegrass. This is admitted by Turtlegrass.” Yntegra recalled a November 29, 2024, letter from Turtlegrass which asserted that “co-existence and mutual success can be achieved through adjustments to your development that respect our guest experience and safety”.

The Rosewood Exuma developer is also arguing that “it is clear that the Town Planning Committee was aware of, and took into account, the environmental concerns of Turtlegrass and the residents of the surrounding area” based on the wording of its March 25, 2026, letter revealing that it had granted preliminary site plan approval.

The CEC 2894 issued by DEPP “applied to the entire project site” for which it was seeking site plan approval, Yntegra is arguing. “The Appeal Board could hardly be expected to override the decision of the experts at DEPP, who are vested with statutory responsibility for the protection of the environment of The Bahamas as to the impact of the developer’s project on the environment,” it asserted.

But Turtlegrass, whose closing submissions at 60 pages dwarfed the seven offered by Yntegra, is arguing exactly the opposite - that the CEC 2894 did not cover all of the Rosewood Exuma project, and that the Town Planning Committee did not assess its complete scope in granting the preliminary site plan approval.

A cornerstone of Turtlegrass’s separate Judicial Review challenge to Rosewood Exuma’s environmental and DEPP approvals is that the project was subject to “salami slicing”, meaning different permits were given for different sections, and at no time was the full development ever revealed to the public. It repeated this in its arguments to the planning Appeal Board.

Reiterating that legal precedent has been established that “a project may not be split into successive stages of decision-making such that no single assessment addresses its total environmental effect”, Turtlegrass asserted: “Preliminary site plan approval was sought and granted for only part of an integrated development.

“It is unacceptable as a matter of principle that the proposed development was inadequately described. Use of the words, in the application, such as ‘proposed project includes’ are deliberately designed to allow the developer to claim he can build what he wants. Such description is deliberately designed to mask the true nature and extent of development and hide from consultees the full extent and harm of what is proposed.

“That the DPP (Department of Physical Planning) permitted such application to be made in that form is a disgrace. The Board needs to ask itself whether – if it dismisses the appeal – those many aspects of development which are not expressly referred to in the application are in fact permitted by the preliminary site plan approval granted by the Town Planning Committee,” Turtlegrass added.

“For example, the on-island wastewater treatment plant, the reverse osmosis plant, the two stormwater management ponds, the deep drainage wells or the solar plant, notwithstanding that all were asserted as part of the same scheme. Are they permitted? And if they are, how can that be consistent with the failure to obtain a CEC which covers the entirety of that development?”

Turtlegrass is also alleging that the Planning and Subdivision Act 2010, the nation’s key planning law, stipulates that the Town Planning Committee must take into account “any environmental impact statements” and cannot ignore the effects that development applications and related decisions have on the environment.

“The appellant attacks the application made in this case because of fundamental failures disclosed by the environmental information which the Planning and Subdivision Act mandates the Town Planning Committee, and now the Subdivision and Development Appeal Board, should have regard to,” it asserted.

“What this is really about is the lengths which the developers and the Department of Physical Planning are going to distract the Subdivision and Development Appeal Board from looking at the environmental information because they know that it falls woefully short and exposes that the EIA is fundamentally deficient.”

Arguing that the Town Planning Committee is tasked with assessing “the acceptability of environmental matters from a planning perspective”, Turtlegrass argued: “It is of the greatest significance that, in giving its decision, the Town Planning Committee failed to even refer to the EIA, still less did it say that it had had regard to its contents.

“Furthermore, and this is a further egregious error, the Town Planning Committee failed to apply conditions to the grant of the preliminary site plan approval which required the development to be undertaken in accordance with even the limited and inadequate mitigation proposals identified in the EIA…It is absolutely clear that there was in this case a blanket refusal by the Town Planning Committee to consider environmental concerns.”

Turtlegrass alleged that this breached the Planning and Subdivisions Act, and pointed to transcripts of the original Town Planning Committee hearing where its then-chairman, Keenan Johnson, said: “We don’t consider environmental concerns when we’re thinking about land use” and “we are only considering town planning considerations, not environmental considerations, which is a totally different department”.

Turtlegrass, though, is arguing that the planning regulators cannot simply defer to DEPP and abdicate all decision-making concerning how environmental issues impact planning. “What the Town Planning Committee did was to unlawfully delegate to DEPP a decision about the acceptability in planning terms of matters which touched or concerned the environment,” it is arguing.


Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment