Advocacy group hails Gillam Bay project halt

An advocacy group has hailed the Supreme Court’s temporary halt to all construction work on Green Turtle Cay’s Gillam Bay project as showing why residents’ environmental concerns must always be heard.

The Save Exuma Alliance, a coalition of business owners, tour operators and residents from that island, backed the imposition of an injunction by Justice Franklyn Williams KC while noting that public consultation for the Seashells at Gillam Bay project only occurred three months after the project’s certificate of environmental clearance (CEC) was granted.

Dr Rihanna Neely-Murphy, director of the Department of Environmental Planning and Protection (DEPP), also determined that the project did not require an environmental impact assessment (EIA), ruling that it would have “low or minimal impact”, which meant no review was necessary.

The Green Turtle Cay community is challenging this decision through the Save Gillam Bay Collective, alleging there was a failure “to make provision for mandatory public consultation” as well as to publish documents so residents could read them and understand full details of the proposed development.

“The ruling is very welcome, and we think it shows the importance of proper consultation and information sharing for proposed development projects. In this instance, even former prime minister Hubert Ingraham encouraged regulators to take a closer look at the development and called for an EIA to be carried out,” said SEA.

“Residents need to know their views are being taken into account, and when approvals are given or consultation carried out without those being consulted having access to complete plans or information, that leaves people feeling sidelined. Big decisions that affect communities and the environment should not be rushed through, especially where they would have a permanent impact on our islands and communities.”

SEA has itself been pushing back on the $200m Rosewood Exuma project planned for Big Sampson Cay by Miami-based group, Yntegra. Residents have raised concerns about the size and density of the development, and its plans for the North Bay, as well as a lengthy seawall and the location of a service dock.

“In Exuma, there was significant opposition to this project..,” SEA said. “The full plans weren’t released until after the consultation ended, so how could people form a complete view and give meaningful input?

“We have similar concerns about the Abaco development. We hope a closer look at these cases leads to a better process, one that makes sure communities are properly consulted on these projects and on those that come after them.”

Justice Williams halted all construction by Seashells at Gillam Bay and its developer, Reginald Curry, to prevent “potential irremediable damage to the environment” as Green Turtle Cay residents bid to overturn its approvals.

His November 11, 2026, verdict temporarily bans all work until the Supreme Court hears and determines the Judicial Review challenge launched against its permits by the Save Gillam Bay Collective, whose members include Green Turtle Cay and Abaco residents including second home owners.

The Save Gillam Bay Collective, in particular, is challenging the decision by Dr Neely-Murphy to grant Mr Curry and his project a certificate of environmental clearance (CEC) on April 22, 2026, without requiring that an environmental impact assessment (EIA) be performed.

Dr Neely-Murphy’s position was that Seashells would produce “low or minimal impact”, which meant no EIA was necessary, although she gave no reasons to explain how this decision - which the DEPP director is empowered to make by the Environmental Planning and Protection Act - was reached.

The Save Gillam Bay Collective, unconvinced by her verdict that an environmental baseline assessment (EBA) and environmental management plan (EMP) would be sufficient for Mr Curry and Seashells, also complained the CEC was granted three months’ before public consultation on the project occurred at a July 22, 2026, Town Hall meeting.

The group then launched its Judicial Review challenge to the CEC and other environmental approvals granted by DEPP, also citing the regulator’s alleged failure “to make provision for mandatory public consultation, the failure to publish the approved EMP, and the failure to publish and make available for inspection any and all attendant statutorily required certificates”.

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment