BEYOND THE BORDERS: Privilege or Price?

FOR more than five decades, Bahamian officials have described US Preclearance as a privilege. When the agreement was signed on April 23, 1974, the description fit. Only three such arrangements existed anywhere in the world. If Preclearance is such a coveted benefit, why have so few countries chosen to take it?

 

The waiting list that never moved

US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) operates Preclearance at 16 airports in six countries: Aruba, The Bahamas, Bermuda, Canada, Ireland, and the United Arab Emirates.

It was not for lack of invitations, either. In 2015 and 2016, the Department of Homeland Security shortlisted 21 foreign airports, including London Heathrow, Amsterdam Schiphol, Tokyo Narita, Mexico City, São Paulo, and St. Maarten. Sweden signed an agreement for Stockholm Arlanda in 2016, and the Dominican Republic signed for Punta Cana the same year. As of this writing, neither has an operating facility, and none of the other shortlisted airports does either.

The reasons are not mysterious. Preclearance requires a host government to permit armed foreign officers to apply foreign law inside its own terminal, to build and maintain the facility, and to bind itself by treaty. The Bahamas, by contrast, renewed its agreement in February 2024 for another generation.

 

What The Bahamas receives

The case for Preclearance is real: The Bahamas welcomed a record 9 million visitors in 2023, most of them Americans. Preclearance allows their flights to land at US airports with no customs facilities, such as LaGuardia.

For Bahamians, the headline benefit is visa-free travel. Under 8 C.F.R. § 212.1(a)(3), a Bahamian may be admitted without a visa if, before departure, he or she satisfies the US immigration officer in The Bahamas of eligibility for admission. In practice, travelers present a passport and a police certificate issued within six months. In 2023, 93 percent of Bahamians processed at Lynden Pindling International Airport (LPIA) traveled that way.

 

What The Bahamas pays

The costs are less visible, and that’s part of the problem. The Bahamas supplies and maintains the Preclearance facility at LPIA. The public has never seen a full accounting of what the government and airport operator spend to host CBP.

When reconstruction of Grand Bahama International Airport stalled, the United States moved in 2022 to end Preclearance in Freeport, and Grand Bahamians without visas lost their direct route.


How the other hosts compare

The fair comparison is not with countries that lack Preclearance, but with those that host it. Bermudians are generally visa-exempt under 8 C.F.R. § 212.1(a)(2), with no Preclearance condition. Arubans travel on Dutch passports under the Visa Waiver Program, as do the Irish. And Canadians need no visa at all. For none of them does visa-free access depend on the facility at home.

The Bahamian exemption is different in kind. Bermudians and Arubans are trusted because of the passport they hold; Bahamians are admitted because of where and how they are screened. Under § 212.1(a)(3), the exemption exists only if the traveler satisfies a US officer in The Bahamas before departure. Yet the same regulation, at § 212.1(a)(4), extends a comparable exemption to British subjects resident in the Cayman Islands and the Turks and Caicos Islands who arrive directly with a Clerk of Court certificate showing no criminal record.

Neither territory hosts Preclearance. Both receive a similar benefit without paying the host’s price.

 

The shrinking value of the bargain

The visa-free benefit is only as valuable as the number of Bahamians who can still use it. A police certificate does not guarantee admission. CBP officers at Preclearance apply the same presumption of immigrant intent found in INA § 214(b) and the inadmissibility grounds of INA § 212(a). A prior visa refusal is not a statutory bar, but a refusal, a revocation, or an old offense can turn a routine departure into secondary inspection, a refusal of admission, or a withdrawal of application for admission. Each outcome is recorded on Bahamian soil and follows the traveler into future applications.

Meanwhile, the State Department’s adjusted B-visa refusal rate for Bahamian nationals rose from 12.81 percent in fiscal year 2024 to 14.46 percent in fiscal year 2025. The figure is modest, but it’s moving in the wrong direction. Figures on revocations and Preclearance refusals of Bahamians are not published.

The result is a two-gate problem. A Bahamian turned away at Preclearance must then seek a visa at the US Embassy and overcome § 214(b) with that record in the file; a later refusal there is visible at the next Preclearance encounter. A Bermudian never faces the second gate. Every Bahamian caught between the two loses the treaty’s principal benefit to Bahamians.

The United States continues to receive everything it bargained for: forward-deployed border screening, security cooperation, and seamless processing of millions of returning American travelers. The Bahamas continues to host and fund the space. 


From privilege to partnership

None of this is an argument to abandon Preclearance. Freeport demonstrated that when Preclearance disappears, Bahamian travelers bear the first and heaviest cost. The argument is that a 50-year-old arrangement should be measured by results rather than reputation. Four steps would help:

Publish the costs. The government should disclose what it spends to host Preclearance, including facility, maintenance, and staffing contributions.

Request the data. Annual figures on refusals, withdrawals, and secondary referrals of Bahamians at LPIA would show whether the benefit is holding or eroding.

Use the consultative process. The agreement’s consultative mechanism should carry measurable service and accountability benchmarks drawn from Aruba and Bermuda.

Renegotiate the foundation. Future agreements should pursue a status-based exemption, on the Bermuda model or the Cayman and Turks and Caicos certificate model, so Bahamian access no longer depends on a facility The Bahamas pays to host.

In 1974, Preclearance was a privilege few nations could claim. In 2026, the fact that so many shortlisted nations never followed through suggests it’s better understood as a transaction. Without a stronger foundation, The Bahamas risks financing a screening system that narrows its own citizens’ access and still calls it a privilege.

 

Donnette Russell-Love is a Florida-licensed attorney with more than 25 years of experience in immigration law, regulatory compliance, and risk management, with a particular focus on US immigration matters affecting The Bahamas and the Caribbean. She is Principal of The Law Office of Donnette Russell-Love, P.L., General Counsel of Immigration Care Service, LLC, and CEO of Global Risk Compliance Group, an SBA-certified Woman-Owned Small Business. A University of Miami School of Law graduate and CAMS-certified, she writes on US immigration, compliance, and cross-border legal issues.

Disclaimer: This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Immigration and border laws and policies change frequently; consult a qualified attorney about your specific circumstances.

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment