Rigorous enforcement vital to Tax Residency Certificate

Matt Aubry, executive director of the Organization for Responsible Governance. 

Photo: Shawn Hanna/Tribune Staff

Matt Aubry, executive director of the Organization for Responsible Governance. Photo: Shawn Hanna/Tribune Staff

BY ANNELIA NIXON

TRIBUNE Business Reporter

anixon@tribunemedia.net

THE BAHAMAS must impose rigorous verification and enforcement measures to prevent abuse of its proposed 90-day tax residency programme and ensure it strengthens the country’s international reputation, governance reformers are warning.

Matt Albury, the Organisation for Responsible Governance’s (ORG) executive director, said the proposed Tax Residency Certificate could entice wealthy international investors and the family offices that manage their affairs to domicile in The Bahamas, but added that its success will heavily depend on the Government’s ability to monitor applicants’ physical presence in this nation and enforce the requirements.

The Government is proposing allowing high-end investors who spend at least 90 days in The Bahamas during a calendar year, with the days not required to be consecutive, to apply for a Tax Residency Certificate. The initiative is intended to strengthen the country’s appeal to internationally mobile wealthy individuals by providing greater certainty over their tax residency status.

Mr Albury said the 90-day threshold could give The Bahamas a competitive advantage, as some other jurisdictions require individuals to spend considerably longer periods in the country to establish tax residency.

“But the biggest issue related to that is making sure that you're auditing all of this, that you've tracked that,” Mr Albury said. “It's not an easy mechanism in a lot of other places. So we really have to ensure that our systems are clear, and our level of enforcement is maybe a little bit more diligent than typically has happened in other levels of systems.”

Mr Aubry added that enabling legislation to give legal effect to the Tax Residency Certificate, which has yet to be released for public review, must clearly establish the verification and enforcement mechanisms governing the programme.

“As we're being reviewed by entities for tax ‘grey lists’ and ‘blacklists’, the strength of these programmes often is in how well they're adhered to and enforced, and how transparent the process is,” he said. “So I do think that's going to be a key thing for the potential advantages that the minister has outlined to manifest.”

Jerome Fitzgerald, minister of economic affairs, has also unveiled plans for the Bahamas Invest Concierge Unit, a proposed one-stop service intended to guide high net worth individuals and family offices through the investment, approvals and permitting process. The initiatives form part of the Government's broader efforts to attract wealthy international investors, encourage family offices to establish operations locally and strengthen The Bahamas' position as an international financial services centre.

However, Mr Aubry said attracting foreign capital must be accompanied by safeguards that protect The Bahamas’ financial services reputation while ensuring the economic benefits extend to Bahamians. He pointed to the financial services industry's existing focus on beneficial ownership transparency and disclosure as an important foundation for maintaining international confidence.

“What's interesting is we have done a kind of cross-sector assessment of corruption practices, anti-corruption practices, rather. And there's a lot that's happening, and particularly in financial services, there's a lot of focus on beneficial ownership and clarity because the external scrutiny is so intense,” Mr Albury said.

He said the Government should build on those existing efforts while strengthening the wider institutional framework for accountability and transparency. The ORG chief also highlighted the importance of fully implementing existing anti-corruption measures, including the Independent Commission of Investigations, whistleblower protections and protected disclosures, as well as the Freedom of Information Act and accompanying regulations.

Mr Aubry said transparency could not be limited to foreign investors or the financial services sector, arguing that The Bahamas’ broader governance framework must reflect the standards it seeks to promote internationally. “But, at the same time, you can't just be accountable and transparent in one area,” he added.

“The mechanisms that have been passed but still are not fully enacted, the anti-corruption bodies like the Independent Commission of Investigations, the whistleblowers, protected disclosures, even things like Freedom of Information, all of those things contribute to a culture that helps to reinforce the kind of narrative you want to put out there.”

The ORG executive director said the proposed Tax Residency Certificate programme could also create opportunities to secure more meaningful economic contributions from participating family offices, including Bahamian employment, investment in infrastructure and support for communities.

Mr Aubry suggested the Government could establish requirements for a certain proportion of Bahamian employees within family offices and consider linking certificate renewals to contributions to registered local non-profit organisations (NGOs) or other demonstrated community commitments.

He added that the Certificate is intended, in part, to regularise the circumstances of individuals who already have permanent residency and live in The Bahamas but have not necessarily established their wider business interests here.

The ORG chief said the arrangements must deliver value not only to foreign investors but also to Bahamians, the domestic economy and the country's international reputation.

Mr Aubry said ORG has consistently advocated for a balance between offering concessions and opportunities to foreign investors and strengthening the domestic economy. He cautioned that an increased reliance on foreign investment could leave The Bahamas vulnerable, pointing to the lessons exposed by the COVID-19 pandemic.

“ORG has always advocated that there needs to be a responsible balance for concessions and opportunities that we present for foreign direct investment and attention to our local economic environment,” Mr Aubry said.

“We all learned from COVID that depending too much on folks from elsewhere really puts us at risk. And so building the stability and the capacity and the growth, the development rather of our local economy, has to be prioritised as well.”

He acknowledged the Government's rationale for establishing a fast-track approval process for high net worth investors, noting that it could bring resources into the economy more quickly. However, Mr Aubry said similar attention must be given to Bahamian businesses that continue to face bureaucratic challenges when seeking to establish or expand their operations.

He acknowledged that the Government had made progress in streamlining business processes, including through expanded digital services, but said further improvements are necessary to ensure Bahamian entrepreneurs can benefit from the investment the country hopes to attract.

“So if we're going to create fast tracks for those high-level components, we also have to make sure that there's an equal amount of effort ensuring that our local businesses are growing and thriving, and able and ready to be able to take advantage of new businesses and new resources that are coming into the country,” Mr Aubry said.

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment