Fresh Cabbage Beach fence concerns voiced

Cabbage Beach on Paradise Island.

Cabbage Beach on Paradise Island.

By ANNELIA NIXON

TRIBUNE Business Reporter

anixon@tribunemedia.net

AN ADVOCACY group yesterday asserted that another fence is being erected at Cabbage Beach without the advance public notice previously promised, while uncertainty over public access, property boundaries and the safety of beachgoers remains unresolved.

Selina Archer, founder of Dis We Beach, told Tribune Business that work being done on Cabbage Beach, which is believed relates to fencing, has raised fresh concerns about the Government’s handling of the proposed $550m Four Seasons Ocean Club Residences development, particularly after officials previously acknowledged that the public should have been given advance notice of previous barriers.

She said Dr Rhianna Neely-Murphy, director of the Department of Environmental Planning and Protection (DEPP), has acknowledged administrative issues and the need to notify the public ahead of another temporary fence being put up to ensure the public’s safety during construction work.

“Dr Rhianna came on and basically said that they have their administrative issues, and that they were supposed to give the public advance notice,” Ms Archer said. “And I think on September 28, they also alluded to the fact or said that they had to give advance notice. So that is the problem. They did not do any of that.” 

She added that the return of the fencing was particularly concerning given the potential for rough surf to reach the same areas where beachgoers could be placed at risk.

“And the surf is back up,” Ms Archer said. “So we don’t know when the surf is coming back up to the fence either. Like in certain sections, you could literally see where the surf is coming back up in the same spot where Rosanna almost lost her life.” 

Ms Archer said there is also no clear indication of where members of the public would be able to access the beach once the fencing is reinstalled, despite previous discussions about arrangements to preserve this access.

“There was no indication of where the public will actually access the beach. That was another thing. Remember, in the EIA, they had the containers that they were going to put up and all of this good stuff,” she said, referring to the environmental impact assessment (EIA).

Ms Archer added that the location of the proposed public beach access has previously been raised, but the group has yet to receive clarity on how the arrangements would work in practice.

Dis We Beach is also seeking clarification over the actual property boundary, with Ms Archer saying a petition submitted to government agencies on October 6 had requested that the boundary line be identified.

“The other thing is that we have a petition out there that asks for the boundary line because I could show you where the stake is, and I could show you where the stake is in relation to the fencing that is going up. So where is the actual property boundary? Nobody seems to know this,” she said.

The latest concerns come amid continuing uncertainty over the relocation of Cabbage Beach vendors to Goodman’s Bay, where the arrival of displaced operators has contributed to mounting tensions with established businesses.

Ms Archer said the relocation process had placed vendors in an increasingly difficult position by transferring them to an already established beach destination during the slow tourism season, without adequately accounting for the resources and existing operators there.

“What they did is they put them in the slow season, especially, into one beach that has their resources,” she said. “So now they’re not just affecting the resources of the Cabbage Beach vendors. They’re now dealing with the resources of the Goodman’s Bay ones.

“So it’s like they put them into an impossible situation to start with. And they didn’t do it properly. They had no public notice. They had no information. It’s been cloak and dagger. Just been ridiculous.” 

Ms Archer said around eight or nine Cabbage Beach vendors still need to be relocated, but questioned whether sufficient space exists at Goodman’s Bay to accommodate them without further aggravating disputes.

“They don’t have spots for them on Goodman’s,” she said. “You see the problems that’s happening on Goodman’s. And I think it’s about eight or nine that need to be relocated.”

Ms Archer also questioned whether alternative locations, including Montagu Beach and the Arawak Cay Fish Fry area, could provide commercially viable opportunities for the displaced operators.

“They’re trying to put them to Montague, and there is no tourist market out in Montague,” she said. “So you can’t just stick people on a beach. Where are the tourist markets for Montague? They don’t have any.” 

Ms Archer added that proposals to place some vendors near the Fish Fry have also encountered resistance from existing businesses concerned about additional competition and limited operating space.

“Again, the businesses of Fish Fry have an issue with that because now you are impeding on what other people are trying to make,” she said. “There’s not enough space for these guys to be able to operate in the manner in which they were operating here, and everything be OK. People have to be able to make a living. They have neglected them so much in this process,” she added.

The relocation dispute has already contributed to a wider confrontation at Goodman’s Bay, where established vendors have complained that the arrival of Cabbage Beach operators has intensified competition for customers and limited space.


Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment