By NEIL HARTNELL
TRIBUNE Business Editor
nhartnell@tribunemedia.net
A FURIOUS court battle over a well-known Briland tourism operator, which featured allegations of more than $1m in unpaid Bahamian taxes, a “fraudulent” Business Licence and ‘fronting’ on behalf of a foreign investor, has been settled.
Legal documents obtained by Tribune Business reveal that Julian ‘Shaq’ Gibson, principal of Conch & Coconut’s Harbour Island-based operations, and his estranged US business partner, Pablo Conde, have agreed to end their war in both the Bahamian and south Florida federal courts on terms that remain undisclosed.
The settlement, which mandates all parties “take certain actions” and release “existing and potential” legal claims against each other within 60 days, meaning the dispute is scheduled to cease before year-end, comes following a Friday, October 23, mediation hearing that sought to resolve their differences without having to go to a full trial in either The Bahamas or the US.
“The parties participated in a mediation on Friday, October 23, 2026, and agreed to settlement terms,” a joint filing by Mr Gibson, Mr Conde and all other parties reveals.
“A binding term sheet has been executed by the parties which requires them to take certain actions within 60 days in exchange for dismissal of this action and the litigation in The Bahamas, and a release of their existing and potential claims against one another.”
The settlement was announced through filings with the south Florida federal court on October 26, 2026, and October 30, 2026. Neither Mr Gibson nor Mr Conde responded to Tribune Business requests seeking comment before press time last night.
The agreed resolution brings to an end a near-16 month battle before both the Bahamian Supreme Court and its US counterpart that was sparked by the bitter divorce, and messy break-up, of the business relationship between Mr Gibson and Mr Conde that developed Conch & Coconut as a “high-end concierge and destination management” provider in one of this nation’s most prominent tourism hot-spots.
The battle also ensnared Corcoran CA Christie, the Bahamian real estate firm, which was named as a defendant in Mr Conde’s Florida lawsuit largely on the basis that Mr Gibson was one of its agents and it had benefited from his Conch & Coconut activities. The late October court filings reveal that Corcoran CA Christie is one of the parties to the settlement deal, so all legal claims made by and against it will also be discontinued.
Tribune Business previously reported that Mr Conde, who describes himself as the founder and owner of Conch & Coconut LLC, the US-based arm of the business, had accused Mr Gibson, who managed the Harbour Island end on his behalf, and others of stealing “the brand and business structure” that he financed and built.
His original lawsuit, filed in the south Florida federal court on Friday, September 5, 2025, claimed Mr Gibson and his associates engaged in “theft of trade secrets” and “unfair competition” by obtaining Conch & Coconut’s customer data, and “cancelling” or closing out its existing bookings, ahead of launching a rival business offering the same services under the same brand name.
Mr Conde, who alleged that Conch & Coconut agreed to sell its business and all Bahamas-based assets to Mr Gibson in October 2023, with the latter to pay the $725,711 purchase price over a ten-year period, asserted that the deal stipulated he retain ownership of the company’s “intellectual property until the final payment was made”.
Claiming that none of the payments required under the deal have been made, Mr Conde sought unspecified damages on the grounds that his former Bahamian partner has engaged in “trademark counterfeiting” by continuing to use the ‘Conch & Coconut’ name and logo without permission as well as its ‘Crack Open the Good Life’ slogan.
The lawsuit also alleged that Mr Conde and Conch & Coconut were forced “to step in and intervene with Bahamian authorities” to pay more than $550,000 in outstanding taxes, legal and consultancy fees to enable Mr Gibson to restart Briland-based operations. Darron Pickstock, now-minister of state for Immigration, but then a private attorney with Glinton, Sweeting & O’Brien, was hired to help regularise its affairs.
Despite this, the Department of Inland Revenue was allegedly still claiming that the Bahamian operation owed $825,000 in unpaid VAT and other taxes, of which $320,000 represented penalties and sanctions. Mr Conde and Conch & Coconut blamed this on Mr Gibson’s alleged failure “to keep reliable accounting records, with the Bahamian tax authorities “questioning its books” from 2018 through to 2021.
Tribune Business reported in March 2023 how Mr Gibson and Conch & Coconut had some of their assets seized after Department of Inland Revenue (DIR) officials, supported by the Royal Bahamas Police Force, conducted an island-wide sweep of companies suspected of not being properly licensed, failing to pay VAT and other due taxes, and under-declaring or under-reporting revenues.
Mr Gibson, though, blamed Mr Conde for the outstanding Bahamian taxes, which at one point exceeded $1m, arguing that he had been “saddled with a large tax obligation due to his actions” and forced to “negotiate a settlement with Inland Revenue”.
“In reality, the tax obligation was always owed by Mr Conde and/or LLC,” Conch & Coconut’s Bahamian partner argued. “Subject to, and without waving the foregoing objections, Mr Gibson states that from the outset and until May 2025, the LLC collected 100 percent of the revenue generated by Mr Gibson and Ltd. Thus, LLC controlled 100 percent of all revenue and cash flow, and was responsible for the payment of Bahamian taxes from those proceeds.
“In addition, LLC’s and Mr Conde’s legal obligation to pay the taxes was memorialised in – but was not created by – the C&L agreement. Since May 2025, and plaintiff’s [Mr Conde’s] breach or repudiation of the C&L agreement, Ltd has made all required VAT payments, past and present, on a timely basis pursuant to an agreed-upon payment plan with Department of Inland Revenue.”
The ‘C&L Agreement’ refers to the October 2023 deal struck between Mr Gibson and Mr Conde, whereby the former would acquire the assets of the Bahamian operations via a so-called lease from his erstwhile US partner, while the latter was to pay the outstanding tax debts owed to the Department of Inland Revenue.
And Mr Gibson, in other legal filings, countered that he was “used as an unwitting ‘front’ to deceive” both the Government and Bahamian law. Tour operations, destination management and vacation rentals are supposed to be exclusively reserved for 100 percent Bahamian ownership under the National Investment Policy, which is a policy rather than a law, but Mr Conde is a US citizen.
“Mr Conde and LLC set up the business structure with Mr Gibson and then Ltd with an intent to deceive the Bahamian government,” Mr Gibson alleged in legal filings. “In The Bahamas, ‘fronting’ refers to the illegal or prohibited practice where a Bahamian acts as a nominal owner or ‘public face’ of a business to facilitate its operation while a foreign national is the true owner and beneficiary.
“This scheme is used to bypass the National Investment Policy, which restricts business sectors exclusively for Bahamians. LLC set this up without Mr Gibson’s knowledge and used him as an unwitting ‘front’ with an intent to deceive the Bahamian government and circumvent the laws/policies of The Bahamas.”
Mr Conde also admitted in his own legal filings how a purported “scam artist” allegedly duped himself and his associates into procuring a “fraudulent Business Licence” despite being paid a $2,000 sweetener to ensure its speedy issuance.
He asserted in an October 20, 2025, affidavit, that he was fooled into thinking the fake permit - which caused the Royal Bahamas Police Force and Department of Inland Revenue to shut Conch & Coconut’s Briland operation down - was a genuine and legitimate document.
Suggesting he and his associates were seeking to help Mr Gibson, exhibits attached to Mr Conde’s affidavit revealed they made a $2,000 under-the-counter payment to “expedite” obtaining the Business Licence and beat the Department of Inland Revenue’s “backlog”.
Mr Conde admitted: “After Gibson failed to timely obtain a valid Business Licence for himself and Conch & Coconut, [Conch & Coconut LLC, the Florida-based entity] attempted to help him by asking its Bahamian contacts for anyone who could help obtain a Business Licence on an expedited basis.
“Unfortunately, the person that was recommended and ultimately used appears to have been a scam artist who provided the allegedly fraudulent Business Licence…. To-date, however, we have not been provided with any evidence or communication from the Government showing that it was actually a fraudulent licence.”
Meanwhile, in The Bahamas, Justice Simone Fitzcharles, in an August 7, 2026, verdict ordered the appointment of an “independent administrator” over Conch & Coconut’s booking platform. She said this was an effort to balance the warring parties’ competing interests with Mr Gibson demanding access to booking and customer information while Mr Conde argued all such data was “proprietary” and is owned by himself.
The south Florida legal settlement will likely involve the end of that independent administrator’s role.



Comments
Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.
Sign in to comment
OpenID