‘Appetite’ to transfer Freeport’s management - but not to Gov’t

By NEIL HARTNELL

TRIBUNE Business Editor

nhartnell@tribunemedia.net

A FORMER Grand Bahama Chamber of Commerce president yesterday suggested there is “appetite” for transferring Freeport’s management and administrative functions - to a newly-created local authority, and not the Government in Nassau.

Dillon Knowles told Tribune Business that, while the Davis administration clearly wants The Bahamas’ second city to be governed by itself from New Providence, “you don’t have to leave Grand Bahama” to see why most Freeport residents are against as neither East End nor West End - the areas under the Government’s control - have “not had anything done for more than 70 years”.

A former senior executive at the Grand Bahama Port Authority (GBPA), he again questioned what the Government is trying to achieve with its recently-launched six-month public consultation and proposed governance reforms for the island “that cannot be done with the Hawksbill Creek Agreement” and amending Freeport’s founding treaty.

The Government’s ‘green paper’ on its planned Freeport and Grand Bahama reforms, which at present involve “reforming, repealing and replacing” various unspecified parts of the Hawksbill Creek Agreement; removing management and administration of the city from the GBPA to the Government; and creating a Grand Bahama Development Council as a “monitoring and co-ordination” body, is silent on what this means for taxation in Freeport.

Mr Knowles said the resulting uncertainty over whether the Government will seek to impose levies such as real property tax, should it succeed in taking back Freeport’s governance, is precisely why he warned against proceeding with changes he compared to someone who “keeps pulling on a thread” that ultimately unravels.

Freeport, under the Hawksbill Creek Agreement, is currently exempt from all types of income, capital gains and inheritance taxes, as well as real property taxes, but several sources have suggested this may change if the Government succeeds in taking back control from the GBPA. In particular, they have suggested that the Business Licence fees paid by companies in the rest of The Bahamas could be imposed in the city.

Mr Knowles, though, said that while it receives licence fees from its 3,500 business licensees, and other permit levies, the GBPA “itself doesn’t get paid a lot of fees”. The service charges paid for every subdivision go to the specific developer, such as Lucaya Services Company (LUSCO), a GBPA affiliate, as the developer of Lucaya.

Existing GBPA licensees will also likely be shielded from any new and increased taxation if the Government upholds the existing rights, benefits and concessions they presently enjoy under the Hawksbill Creek Agreement or transfers them to present investment incentive legislation, such as the Industries Encouragement Act.

However, the Government has already required existing businesses and other Port Area property owners to obtain a real property tax assessment number - a move many interpret as a key step towards finally implementing the tax in the city.

Mr Knowles, though, said that Grand Bahama is presently treated like all Family Islands for real property tax purposes, meaning that Bahamian-owned property is exempt and that - outside Freeport - only foreign-owned property is liable.

“One of the things that has to be taken into consideration is currently, separate and apart from the Hawksbill Creek Agreement, Grand Bahama for real property tax purposes is considered a Family Island, which exempts Bahamians from paying,” he added. “It doesn’t exempt foreign property owners.

“If the Government were to decide it wanted to tax property owners in Grand Bahama, including Freeport, the law that exists allows it to tax foreign property owners, not Bahamian property owners. But that doesn’t mean the Government couldn’t change the law to put Grand Bahama in the same bucket as New Providence for real property tax.”

Mr Knowles, though, said the taxation complexities surrounding Freeport are but one factor that needs to be considered and addressed properly in any reform initiative. “There are a lot of moving parts to it,” he told Tribune Business, “which is why I said if you keeping pulling on the thread it’s going to unravel.

“We need to be careful about what we’re trying to do, but the fact is the people of Grand Bahama don’t want central government running Grand Bahama. I think that there is an appetite for transferring the administrative functions from the two families [the Haywards and St Georges, the GBPA owners] but transferring it to a local authority, not to central government and run out of New Providence.

“We’ll have to see how this all plays out. Obviously, the Government would like it to be run from Nassau. You don’t have to leave Grand Bahama to see the difference between the areas that the Government runs and the area the private developer runs. East and West End have not had anything done to them in 70 years of the Hawksbill Creek Agreement.”

Freeport’s founding treaty includes a provision for devolving the GBPA’s city management and administrative powers to a newly-created local authority if 80 percent of the latter’s licensees vote in favour of such a move. “The way I look at it, the Government has not articulated clearly and specifically what the problem is that it’s trying to solve.

“It’s articulated some under-performance, but has not articulated what has caused this under-performance. Therefore, it’s articulated a solution that’s looking for a problem rather than a problem looking for a solution.

“On the face of it, it’s a takeover. It is hard to see what the Government is trying to do that cannot be done with the existing Agreement; within the framework of the existing Agreement. It provides for the transfer of administrative authority. This wholesale overhaul and replacement of the Agreement just doesn’t make practical sense.”

Mr Knowles added that the GBPA is not a quasi-governmental entity as its responsibility is simply to “administer the rules and concessions” detailed in the Hawksbill Creek Agreement on the Government’s behalf “no different from any island administrator in the Family Islands”.

As a result, he said: “This discussion about sovereignty and the authority of the Port Authority is “a false flag discussion being used to justify” the Government’s strategy and tactics.


Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment