Judge says teen deliberately armed himself and returned to attack victim

By LYNAIRE MUNNINGS

Tribune Staff Reporter

lmunnings@tribunemedia.net

A 19-YEAR-OLD man who deliberately armed himself with a knife and returned to confront another man before stabbing him in an attack that could have been fatal has been sentenced to ten years’ imprisonment for attempted murder.

Xavier Longley was sentenced by Supreme Court Justice Darron Ellis after pleading guilty to attempting to murder Donovan Colebrook during an altercation on May 24, 2025.

In the ruling, Justice Ellis said the seriousness of the offence was heightened by Longley’s decision to leave the initial confrontation, return to his home to obtain a knife and then go back to confront Colebrook.

The judge said Longley had an opportunity to walk away from the dispute but instead chose to arm himself and return, demonstrating a degree of planning and deliberation that increased his culpability.

During a police interview on May 26, 2025, Longley admitted obtaining the knife from his home and wanting to kill Colebrook.

According to the agreed facts outlined in court, Colebrook received a telephone call from Alicia Leslie at around 10pm on May 24, 2025, and subsequently went to her residence, where he encountered Leslie and Longley.

An altercation broke out between the two men, after which Longley left the premises. He later returned carrying a knife and stabbed Colebrook in the left buttock, prompting Colebrook’s father to rush him to hospital.

In determining the sentence, Justice Ellis considered the seriousness of the injury, Longley’s age, his previous good character, prospects of rehabilitation and the circumstances surrounding his guilty plea.

The court was told that Colebrook continued to experience physical and emotional difficulties following the stabbing.

In a statement provided to the probation officer, Colebrook described undergoing exploratory surgery after suffering repeated punches to his abdomen.

He also reported difficulties with bowel movements, impaired movement in his left ankle, abrasions and ulcers on the underside of his foot, and a limp that affected his mobility and ability to work as a hotel server.

He further described financial difficulties arising from medical expenses, as well as anxiety and feelings of insecurity when in public.

However, the judge noted that no medical report was provided to establish the medical cause of the reported difficulties or whether they would result in permanent disability.

Justice Ellis said the injury was nevertheless serious and potentially fatal, although the absence of proven permanent injury was relevant when comparing the case with others involving repeated attacks or lifelong consequences.

The judge identified the deliberate decision to return armed with a knife as the principal aggravating factor.

However, he also gave substantial consideration to Longley’s personal circumstances, including that he was 18 at the time of the offence, had no previous convictions and had demonstrated an ability to maintain employment before his incarceration.

According to the probation report, Longley was raised primarily by his mother, Natasha McKenzie, in a close-knit household with his younger brother. His family described him as quiet, mannerly, kind and reserved, and expressed surprise at his involvement in the offence.

The report also noted that he had obtained several Bahamas General Certificate of Secondary Education passes, including a B in Spanish and Cs in English and Religious Studies, although he did not complete high school.

He subsequently worked for several businesses before securing employment as a procurement associate at Baha Mar, where he had worked for approximately two weeks before being incarcerated.

Justice Ellis said Longley’s youth, previous good character, family support and prospects of rehabilitation warranted a meaningful reduction in his sentence.

The Crown had argued that the seriousness of the offence justified a sentence of between 15 and 20 years, emphasising that Longley had deliberately armed himself and returned to attack Colebrook.

However, the defence urged the court to impose six years, arguing that a lengthy prison term would fail to account adequately for his age, remorse, guilty plea and potential for rehabilitation.

Justice Ellis said neither proposed sentence was appropriate and adopted a starting point of 18 years’ imprisonment. He reduced that term by three years to account for Longley’s personal mitigating circumstances, leaving 15 years before consideration of his guilty plea.

Although Longley initially pleaded not guilty, he changed his plea on August 7, 2026, the morning his trial was scheduled to begin, after the jury had been selected but before evidence was called.

The judge acknowledged that the plea was not entered at the earliest opportunity, but said it spared Colebrook and other witnesses from having to give evidence and avoided a contested trial.

He also considered Longley’s admissions during his police interview, including his acknowledgement that he intended to kill Colebrook.

Justice Ellis ultimately applied a one-third reduction, equivalent to five years, bringing the sentence to 10 years’ imprisonment.

The judge said the final sentence was proportionate to the seriousness of the offence, Longley’s culpability and his personal circumstances.

Longley was also ordered to receive credit for the time he has spent on remand since August 11, 2026.

Additionally, Justice Ellis recommended that the Bahamas Department of Correctional Services assess Longley’s counselling needs and make appropriate counselling available during his incarceration.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.