STATESIDE: Florida stands firm as Democrats sweep across America

A political email drifted in from cyberspace last week. “Patriot,” it began, “while Democrats were winning elections all across our country last week, there was one state that held fast for conservatives and the Republican Party. That state was Florida.

“The Republican Party swept to victory in every statewide race in Florida. The GOP won the race for the US Senate, the race for governor, and all other contests for state offices. This successful plan was implemented by Governor Ron DeSantis. 

“Do you think that Governor DeSantis’ plan should be the Republican plan for 2028?”

There was a tab to answer yes or no. There was another tab at the bottom to press if the reader would like to contribute to the Republican Party. Florida did indeed appear to offer a ray of hope in an otherwise depressing election for Republicans. We’ll take a closer look at the situation in Florida in a moment. 

But perhaps the most emphatic punctuation to the Democratic election landslide came after local district attorney Scott Colom was declared the victor last week in Mississippi’s US Senate race. In edging past incumbent Cindy Hyde-Smith, who had held the seat for eight years, Colom becomes the first black senator since 1881 elected from a state in which nearly 40 percent of the population is black – the highest percentage in the US. 

Curiously, Hyde-Smith and Colom share some recent history. Just three years ago, then-president Joe Biden nominated Colom to be a federal judge in the northern district of Mississippi. The Republican governor and Mississippi’s other GOP senator Roger Wicker both supported the nomination, but Hyde-Smith, citing some stale and unconvincing Republican attack talking points, refused. As per Senate procedure, Hyde-Smith’s action killed Colom’s nomination. Colom has reportedly suggested that her gesture helped to inspire his candidacy this time around.

There were many other stunning results around the country, including the election of the first black, female governor ever elected anywhere (a Democrat, she won in Georgia); Democrats sweeping the board of statewide offices in previously solid Red Texas, and Democratic candidates winning Senate seats in South Carolina, Kansas and Ohio, among several other unlikely places. 

It looks like the Dems are also going to prevail in Alaska’s undecided Senate race, bringing their majority to a solid 56-44 advantage. And if Democrats also win the governorship in Alaska where they also currently lead, they are set to hold governorships in 30 of the 50 US states. Almost no one saw this coming. The implications are quite significant, especially if these majorities hold past the next general election in two years. 

Meantime, in Washington, US president Donald Trump may be the sorest loser in modern global political history. He is already backing away from what initially seemed to be a reasonable, almost humble reaction to last Tuesday’s crushing defeats. And he has shown no signs of abandoning his intransigent partisanship, so an extraordinarily fractious and ineffective intragovernmental stalemate looms for the next two years in Washington. 

But not in Florida. Florida, the third most-populous state, withstood the national Democratic surge on Tuesday, remaining a Republican bastion even as the GOP got clobbered almost everywhere else across the electoral map.

“We got wiped out in Texas, the biggest anchor we have in Republican politics,” Florida governor Ron DeSantis said on the day after the election. “So really, Florida is the last main anchor standing.”

Florida Republicans retained a Senate seat, the governor’s mansion and every statewide office on the ballot. Those victories were a point of pride for the national party on a night with few moments to brag about, especially in the South. They appeared to reinforce Florida’s standing as a former battleground state that is now solidly Republican.

DeSantis also mentioned Amendment 3, a constitutional change on Florida’s ballot that was approved. It expands homestead property tax exemptions and lowers the annual assessment cap for certain non-homestead properties, and Republicans had mostly supported the measure. 

Amendment 3, which passed with about 62 percent support, has divided Republican leaders. It is expected to cost local governments billions of dollars in revenue and lead to sharp reductions in public services or to new local fees or taxes — all complications for incoming governor Byron Donalds.

“Donalds is about to be handed a dumpster fire of problems, and we are running a not very nice experiment on 23 million Floridians,” said Jeff Brandes, a former Republican state senator and president of a Florida think tank.

Also, Republicans also lost some of their previous state government margins.

The party will no longer enjoy supermajorities in the state legislature, where Democrats seem poised to gain at least 15 seats, more than they had won in decades. Democrats looked certain to retain eight of the state’s 28 congressional seats, the same number they had before the midterms, even after Republican state lawmakers redrew four districts in a partisan gerrymandering effort earlier this year.

Democrats flipped Miami-Dade County, which Republicans had won in 2022 and 2024. And Republican candidates only narrowly won the races for Senate and governor despite vast advantages in fund-raising and voter registration. In the Florida Senate race, the Democrats nominated Angela Nixon, who has served as a member of the Florida House of Representatives since 2020. Also a member of the Working Families Party and the Democratic Socialists of America, she nearly won despite being outspent by a two-to-one margin. Nixon ran a grass-roots Senate campaign with no television ads.

Senator Ashley Moody, the Republican incumbent who is serving the remainder of Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s original 2022 term, defeated Nixon by about three percentage points. Donalds, the black Republican governor-elect, edged out David Jolly, the Democratic nominee, by about one percentage point — or about 108,000 votes out of more than 8.2 million cast. A Trump favorite and three-term congressman from southwest Florida’s Naples and Ft Myers areas, Donalds’ campaign outspent Jolly by about $150 million.

Florida Republicans held serve, but by worrisomely small margins. In 2022, DeSantis, who is term limited, won re-election by nearly 20 points and Rubio by 16 points. Two years ago, Trump won his adopted home state by 13 points.

“Florida Democrats are looking at the results across the country and can only imagine what kind of day we would be having if we had sustained national support,” said the Florida Democratic Party chair. The Florida Dems feel they were abandoned.

Republicans still have a big advantage in voter registration numbers -- the GOP has a 4-to-3 edge in affiliated voters. State Democratic Party leaders say the national party could have invested in voter registration efforts a year ago to capitalize on the deep voter discontent with Trump and the Republicans.

“It was a missed opportunity — this could have been won,” a Demo. “If we have the resources, we could start to tilt Florida back to a purplish state, or at least light red.”

DeSantis remains the most popular Republican in the state. He did not endorse Donalds or any other Republican in the primary to succeed him. And he made only a few campaign appearances ahead of the general election. Maybe he anticipated the electoral debacle that many polls foresaw.

DeSantis figures to continue to influence party politics in Florida even after leaving the governor’s mansion in Tallahassee. He has governed largely by pushing the limits of his executive power in support of conservative policy priorities. He has told reporters that such an aggressive approach has expanded the state Republican Party by drawing new residents and winning over existing ones who want their elected leaders to stand for something.

At a news conference after the election, he called the national midterm results “as close to an extinction-level event for Republicans in many parts of the country as we have seen probably in the last 100 years.”

Donalds ran a tight, effective campaign. He didn’t hide from the many Trump policies that hurt Republican candidates. Articulate and resolutely on message, Donalds managed to project a clear-eyed loyalty to Trump while appearing to be calm, level-headed and informed. 

But on election night, Donalds took the stage in Broward County to celebrate keeping the governorship in Republican hands since 1999, when Jeb Bush took office.

“Mr. President, I want you to hear from Florida,” he said, addressing Trump. “We are still red.”

Comments

Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.

Sign in to comment