0

Police Officers’ Attorney Says He Would Have Shot Man Who Died In Custody

By SANCHESKA BROWN

Tribune Staff Reporter

sbrown@tribunemedia.net

JAMIE Smith should have died from a close range gunshot wound to the heart, Wayne Munroe told the Coroner’s Court yesterday.

During his closing submissions, Mr Munroe said police officers “ought not to play with felons” who are in custody and can grab a firearm an injure innocent people. He said if it were him he would have just shot Smith rather than struggle to restrain him for several minutes.

But Mr Munroe said because it was not his client’s intention to kill Smith, he chose to place him in a sleeper hold, rather than shoot him.

Smith, 35, died at the Central Detective Unit within two hours of his arrest on suspicion of armed robbery on February 8, 2013.

Four officers from the station, Sergeant Ezra Maycock, Corporal Brian Roach, Corporal Sterling Knowles and Sergeant Keno Smith, have been placed on administrative leave.

A pathologist report later concluded that Smith died of asphyxia, an excess of carbon dioxide caused by abnormal breathing.

Acting Coroner Jeanine Weech-Gomez oversees the inquiry. Attorney Christina Galanos represents Smith’s immediate family and lawyers Wayne Munroe and Ian Cargill represent the officers.

Corporal Roach admitted in earlier testimony that he placed Smith in a sleeper hold to try and calm him down and prevent him from escaping. He testified that the hold is a standard police position used to subdue unruly suspects.

Mr Munroe told the five member jury that their decision in this case will send a clear message to the police force.

He said: ”If you tell police they cannot use this hold, then how should they restrain suspects? Would you prefer they use my method and just shoot the person? Are you, the jury, saying that the Bahamian police ought not to have available to them a technique used all over the world. If he had gotten a firearm from one of the officers it would be a different story. We would be reading the papers and saying ‘These officers must be inept, how did they let this man get a gun?”

Mr Munroe said Smith died from pressure applied to the neck. He said no one choked him, no one beat him and he was not strangled. He said the reason it took Corporal Roach a long time to properly place Smith in the sleeper hold was because he was moving around violently trying to escape custody.

Mr Munroe also told the court that it is not strange that it took four officers to restrain one man, especially when the man in question was “high as a kite.”  A toxicologist testified that Smith had traces of marijuana in his blood.

He said the size of the man does not matter. He reminded the jury that some time ago, one man, who was also under the influence, beat up, six police officers, seriously injuring two of them.

Mr Munroe also said Jamie Smith was a felon and the law permits certain treatment when it comes to felons. He said “people can die before a trial for their felonies, the law permits that.” He said Smith got violent when he realized that officers would figure out that he was not Matthew Pratt, as he originally told them, but that he was actually Jamie Smith. He said facing the possibility that he could spend the rest of his life in prison for armed robbery, Smith decided to escape and the officers could not let him leave as it is an offence to let a felon escape from police custody.

However, Ms Galanis said despite what reputation Smith may or may not have had, it does not give the police the right to play judge, jury and executioner. She said regardless of what may have been said in court about Smith, he died an innocent man. She said Smith had a fundamental right to have a trial and even if he was found guilty his sentence would not have been death.

She told the jury that the officers tried to portray Smith as the aggressor to justify their actions. She said they are hiding behind section 103 of the Penal code which gives officers the right to use any force which is necessary to recapture, arrest or kill a felon trying to escape custody.

However, she said killing him was to be the last resort if he could not otherwise be detained and the evidence does not show that they tried any other means of restraining him. She also questioned why Corporal Roach placed Smith in the sleeper hold without having the proper CPR training to resuscitate him, in fact she said none of the officers performed CPR on Smith.

Ms Galanis also said because of the marijuana that was found in Smith’s system, it would have made him drowsy making it impossible to have the strength to struggle with the police officers.

She said the officers offered no plausible reason how Smith met his death and the message must be sent that no one is above the law. She told the jury to ask themselves “Did four men really have to kill one unarmed man to restrain him?”

The inquest continues on September 5, when the Coroner is expected to sum up the evidence instruct the jury.

Comments

John 6 years, 5 months ago

Since the reputation for police to beat, abuse and manhandle suspects while in custody and to even beat them more seriously and injure them permanently when interrogating them,is well known. Mr. Munroes' suggestion that police shoot a suspect, while in custody, is very dangerous to say the least. If a suspect is acting 'violently' and trying to escape, the first option would be to get him in a cell and secured. If he is known to be on drugs, it is very risky to get in a physical tassle rather than trying to subdue him. Five officers together could easily constrain him and place him in a cell.. To for an educated person suggesting that police shoot a suspect while in custody . where the suspect is supposed to be protected and secure.that's very dangerous ground.

0

xtreme2x 6 years, 5 months ago

I just hope the Jury's could see through what Munroe is implying. the guy is already at a disadvantage with 4 big men, plus he may also be hand cuff. There are too many persons dying at the hands of the police to get information from them. There should be cameras install in all interrogation rooms and in police vehicles and a GPS in all vehicles. They are installing them all around town for criminals. There are criminals in the force to.

0

alexispeack 5 years, 10 months ago

I watched it with the director's commentary (because I love Mann's work)http://www.evilsharpshoot.com/profile...">. He kept talking about how amazing digital "film" ishttp://www.arcadegamescorner.com/prof...">. The film is shot entirely in available light. Pay attention to the last act of the film, it is all just the available light. So when Foxx is on the parking garage it is lit by the reflections off the buildings. At the end it was so dark the actors could not see but the cameras could.

0

leonardo85 5 years ago

It is definitely an unfortunate situation, now his family might file a case or they could demand an investigation. They would need a skilled lawyer to win this case, they could find plenty of law firms which handle such cases. These firms could be accessed online as well, for instance, at http://www.rickplezia.com/FAQ.php">http://www.rickplezia.com/FAQ.php you can find the reputed SUV Rollover Lawyers of Richard J. Plezia & Associates.

0

dana 5 years ago

Sometimes it really becomes difficult to take the right decision. However, the police officers could indeed hire attorneys to defend themselves in such complicated situations. No matter what kind of legal complication you are facing, you can certainly win the case if you hire the best attorney. For instance, If you need a http://singerlaw.net/">family law attorney Sacramento area, you should hire the most reputed lawyer.

0

karina 5 years ago

In such situations one can not put the blame entirely on a particular person, however, everyone could learn some valuable lessons this way. But if someone gets injured due to the fault of an officer then it would be better to hire a personal injury lawyer like Robert Tenbrunsel who is a reputed http://www.ten-law.com/personal-injur...">Sarasota injury lawyer.

0

leonardo85 5 years ago

They have to be cautious in future so that no such incident could ever take place. However, any kind of criminal case is full of complications, only a skilled and experienced attorney could handle such issues. If you search online you can find plenty of good attorneys, for instance, at http://www.lavelylaw.com/choose-an-at...">http://www.lavelylaw.com/choose-an-at... you can find the best accident attorney in St Petersburg.

0

isabella 5 years ago

Such incidents could happen, the officer here was not responsible at all, he was merely doing his duty. However, if the victim's family feels that he was responsible then they should consider hiring an attorney to file a case. However, finding an attorney or law firm is now easier, if you need intellectual property law firm then you can find that at http://jrblaw.com/">http://jrblaw.com/.

0

karina 5 years ago

The officers have to be more cautious in future so that such an incident do not happen again. But the victim's family here can take action against the officer. However, now one can find the law firms online, even if you need a law firm that handles commercial litigation issues, you can find that at http://www.presberg.com/Commercial-Li...">http://www.presberg.com/Commercial-Li....

0

leonardo85 5 years ago

It was an unfortunate incident for the officers involved in the case. But hopefully they would be able to win this case and would not get any punishment. If you have the right attorney with you then you can overcome any kind of legal complication. Just go online and you can find different attorneys there, from a http://taxreliefsystems.net/">tax attorney in Orange County to a criminal defense lawyer in NYC everyone has online presence now.

0

dana 4 years, 11 months ago

Such incidents are bound to raise many questions, but the officer here should not be given any punishment. To sort out such cases one does need to have the best lawyer in town. However, when it comes to finding lawyers or law firms you should go online. For instance, if you need a personal injury lawyer you can find him at http://www.mdevito.com/practice.html">http://www.mdevito.com/practice.html.

0

yilky 4 years, 9 months ago

This is moreover a decent mail which I really savored perusing. It is not ordinary that I have the probability http://trustedantivirussoftwarereview...">best antivirus software

0

yilky 4 years, 9 months ago

Basically needed to educate you that you have individuals like me who admire your work. Doubtlessly an extraordinary post. http://chaturbatetokenshack.com/">online hack

0

yilky 4 years, 9 months ago

I need to urge you to unquestionably proceed with your awesome occupation.. http://chaturbatetokenshack.com/">this site has the best chaturbate tokens generator

0

Sign in to comment