0

Young Man's View: Police, Pmh Don't Agree

By ADRIAN GIBSON

ajbahama@hotmail.com

THE REVELATION that 519 people were shot and stabbed—per Princess Margaret Hospital statistics—which bear a stark contrast to the 10 attempted murders recorded by the Royal Bahamas Police Force (RBPF) for the same period, seems to suggest that some manipulative hanky-panky might have been done to vary the police’s data. Indeed, the statistical disparities between PMH’s data and that which has been reported by the police raises questions about the classification of criminal activities and whether the police or the powers that be cherry-pick which incidents would be categorized are serious or not.

Frankly, the numbers being proffered by the police—relative to the epidemic of criminality engulfing our society—appears to be clearly inaccurate. The Princess Margaret Hospital is the first contact point for most people injured or wounded by a criminal act and therefore the professionals at the hospital would be the most believable in terms of their account of the persons that they treat on an every day basis. One would be more inclined to believe the validity of the Princess Margaret Hospital’s data to that of the police.

In recent times, there has seemingly been a demonstrated interference in the activity of the RBPF. I, and other Bahamians, want to know if the police force, in any way, has been directed to paint a glowing picture by variation of the definitions of the various heads of crime. There is only one truth, there can only be one set of facts! So, what are the tools that the police are using, how are the assumptions being made relative to the crime statistics? The Bahamian public deserves and wants to hear the truth and, quite honestly, the apparent fudging of the crime statistics is demonstrative of the importance of the Freedom of Information Act towards strengthening our democracy.

When one looks at the hyperbole, the melodrama and all the “flammin’” surrounding the so-called BTC deal, one notes that we live in an era where such inanity could only happen in an environment cloaked in secrecy. Why won’t the government let the Bahamian people see the documents and the agreement concerning the so-called take back? Why hasn’t the public seen ALL of the transactions between Cable and Wireless and the current and previous administration? Is there a reason why we can’t see it?

Yesterday, I was reliably informed that the medical records department at PMH reviews all emergency room visits using computer data and hard copies as well as looking at the diagnostic code related to patient visits. I was emphatically told that “everything is recorded.”

By all accounts, PMH’s emergency room is one of the busiest in the world. According to a noted physician, PMH has more than 50,000 visits per annum. Dr Duane Sands, Head of the Accident and Emergency Department from 1997 to 2002, told me that they have been “collating patient visits and determining if we have a paediatric patient to medical problems to surgical patients to road traffic victims to assaults, whilst also specifically honing in on gun shots and stabbings.”

Asked whether there were any methodological issues concerning the data collected by PMH, Dr Sands said: “If there were methodological issues in a retrospective review—which may or may not capture some information depending on who is doing the coding—we have sought to sort that out. When we renovated the emergency department—introducing a trauma room, putting a lab in the emergency department, introducing a large asthma bay, increasing the footprint of the emergency room—we simultaneously modified the medical recording areas to record data. The impetus for the modifying of the patient encounter sheet in the emergency department came from a desire to be able to perform an injury surveillance study that would allow clinicians to give valid data to policy makers so that it could inform decision making. Since the modified forms is my baby, every year I request the crime data. I don’t know how many other people look at the data, but I do. All of the presentations and comments I have made are consistent with that data. I believe that the data from the emergency room is consistent with the reality of my day-to-day clinical practice and all of the perceptions we may have about overcrowding on the ward, inadequacy of room and the impact of violence and trauma on the other medical departments. ”

According to Dr Sands, the recently released crime statistics are “also validated by the discussions we have in our quality control meetings every Wednesday morning at PMH, where we discuss our mortality and morbidity experiences and review the management of complex cases.”

An anonymous source at PMH—who wished to remain unnamed—told me that relative to rapes, a dedicated room was created in the emergency department at PMH, specifically for the human evaluation and treatment of alleged rape victims. Known as the Agape room, if there is any clinical problem subject to rigorous, protocol-driven management, it would be an alleged rape. As it stands, I’m told that women are taken out of the chaos of the general emergency department and placed in a quiet, comfortable area because they have been so traumatized. In that vein, if one were to question the validity and reliability of any subset of patients, it appears that the public can rest assured that that would likely be coded properly. If PMH has such a room, where they pay special care to rape victims, the statistics related to rape—that they individually take on a one-on-one basis—are most likely truthful and accurate. If a woman subsequently withdraws the allegation and decides not to press charges, or be coerced sometimes by prominent public officials to drop charges, it doesn’t change the validity of the original complaint made between patient and physician. There is no reason to doubt that if there are a specific number of cases reported in the logs of accident and emergency at PMH and that in and of itself leads one to conclude that it is quite certain that a woman would’ve been sexually traumatized. Is that not what women are concerned about!

Frankly, the Bahamian people are entitled to know the actual prevalence of incidents of rape and other sexual crimes happening in the Bahamas!

Indeed, in the Bahamas, the gun has become the great equalizer of men. As a good friend of mine told me yesterday, “with a gun, any 85 pound, four feet 10 inch punk becomes godlike in his ability to control the destiny of the people at whom he points a gun.” Quite honestly, a young punk with a gun gets to decide whether one lives or dies, whether one “frees up or not—and even though one’s opponent or prey may have a natural advantage in size or speed, such a person is seldom able to neutralize the advantage of having a powerful handgun or assault rifle. According to my friend, “it is not rocket science, we are no different in New Providence than it is in South Central L.A.; Detroit; Kingston, Jamaica; or Camden, New Jersey.”

Indeed, we are currently witnessing the extermination of young males in the Bahamas. Young men—a demographic to which I belong—are being cut down by other primarily black, young men. Our people are dying and we can pretend all we want that we don’t have a problem or that this year’s crime statistics or that year’s crime statistics is not as bad as the year before. We would only be playing a numbers games and fooling ourselves.

On Gaming Board Chairman Dr Andre Rollins

I support Dr Andre Rollins’ attempt to admonish the government—of which he’s a part—to bring resolution to the web shop operations in the wake of last year’s failed referendum where citizens voted “no” on questions proffered by the government in its opinion poll. According to Dr Rollins, the government appears to be “afraid to act”, preferring that foreigners own casinos whilst refusing to move legislation to legalize internet gaming for Bahamians. He also criticized the Bahamas Christian Council (BCC) for being selective in its fight against the immorality of web shop gambling whilst glazing over casino gambling and not demonstrating the same zeal to reject the “immorality” that—based on the church’s position—should also relate to casino gaming.

Yes, the current administration must either get on with regulating the web shops and local gaming (a position I would support considering the practicality of it all) or totally shut down web shop operations. If the government regulates web shop gaming, the BCC will no doubt loudly protest and many people would feel that the wishes of some members of the electorate—expressed via the referendum results—was discarded. However, considering the prevalence of web shop gambling (a national pastime), the need for funds and the government’s proposal to implement VAT, the administration has the numbers to simply get on with regulating the local industry.

Kudos to Rollins for having the gumption and the wherewithal to speak the truth even when it could adversely affect his political standing within his own party!

Death of Long Islander Shervin Smith

A few weeks ago, my good friend Shervin “Smithy” Smith passed away.

Smithy was one of Long Island’s greatest ambassadors. Every time I went to Long Island, I would run into him at the airport or hear from him once he knew I was there. He was also a taxi driver, driving taxi number 10 , so it was hard for Smithy to be missed or not know when I landed. The last time I saw him was during the summer, when he came and sat with me as I waited for my flight and we discussed my business in Long Island, politics (a favourite topic of his), my columns and radio appearances, his health and life in general.

I knew that Smithy was battling cancer as he had asked me to do something for him before and when I dropped it off at his second home in Golden Gates—where he stayed when he came to Nassau—he made the revelation to me. This was more than a year ago.

I will never forget his love for Long Island and how he always called to make an input into a column or informing me of some happening in Long Island. Smithy was a friend and a community builder, having also served on the Local Government Board for a number of years. I’ll miss his chatter and his way of calling and starting a conversation by saying “boy, Adrian this or that....”

My sincere condolences are expressed to his family. May his soul rest in peace.

Comments

sheeprunner12 8 months, 3 weeks ago

Adrian, please do some more investigative reporting.................. uncover the PLP scab

0

Honestman 8 months, 3 weeks ago

A man has just been discovered in a shallow grave - will this be classified as unlawful burial? The change in classifications of crimes can only have been designed to mislead the public and I don't care what the Police Commissioner says. The PLP made itself look foolish in the build up to the last election when it planted posters in prominent places advertising the murder count to all and sundry. Now it has "egg on its face " as it is obvious to all that serious crime has gotten even worse under its watch. Then Mother Pratt has the nerve to say that crime shouldn't be politicized! This administration will resort to anything to try and mislead the gullible and "save face". If it comes down to PMH's statistics versus the government's, I think we all know who to believe.

0

sheeprunner12 8 months, 3 weeks ago

POLITRICKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Who can you believe?????????????? COP, PGC, PMH???????????

This is the first sign of complete social implosion

THE FOURTH ESTATE MUST STAND UP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

0

TalRussell 8 months, 3 weeks ago

Comrade SheepRrunner this is the Señor "Fifth Estate" Comrade informing you that I see you is once again falling behind the times in we Bahamaland cause even my 103 year old grandma Ellen does know the Fourth Estate done be too damn occupied standing up for either the PLP, or them kicked out power red shirts. The rest population are quickly being turned into shareholders of we former public utilities corporations, or Beer making foreign corporate financed by the reds using $11 million of the workers NIB monies. The power now rests on the shoulders all we brave Comrade "Fifth Estate" bloggers.

0

Apostle 8 months, 3 weeks ago

This is a sad day in The Bahamas when everybody wants to tell the commissioner how to do his job. I don't see anybody telling Dr. Sands how to report his stats and I really don't see why we are having this debate unless it is sheer political posturing.

One would expect that intelligent people like Dr. Sands would understand that what the commissioner is reporting is crime reports. I never heard the commissioner or anybody say that that is all the crime that occurs. These are the ones that are reported.

A male is shot and turns up at PMH for treatment. Dr. Sands and his team treats him and notify the police. The police shows up at PMH and the male says he wish no complaint. Folks for the police they cannot report that, because it is essentially not a crime. The same is the case where a woman is raped and shows up at the hospital. She is examined by the doctor and gets the HIV and morning after treatment and when the police sees her, she refuses to make a complaint. That is her rights. The police cannot report that as a rape in the sense because it is not a report to them. The hospital would have it as a rape, but not the police.

So as cynical as it may seem, we have to all learn how to accept and respect the agencies. The nonsense that the PLP did during the run up to the election will always be a haunting reminder of using people's hurt for political gain. Unfortunately the FNM is doing the very same thing. It was foolish then and it is still foolish now for him to be parading around making it seem as though the COP did something wrong or was influenced by the political directorate.

To add insult to injury the media is just as bad. The COP made his report and they published it. Dr. Sands gives his figures and the media says they don't match the police's so the police lie. Would someone please tell me why nobody is questioning Dr. Sands' figures or motives for him bringing the police's statistics into his discussion, because I don't hear the COP speaking and I hope he has nothing more to say on the topic.I hope and pray that all grieving families now rise up an voice their concerns and all of us get an appreciation of what it feels like to lose a loved one and to see sensible people attempting to make political or whatever mileage on their loss.

0

Sign in to comment