0

COB study reaction: 'Culture condones men being in charge'

photo

Dr Sandra Dean Patterson

By RASHAD ROLLE

Tribune Staff Reporter

rrolle@tribunemedia.net

BAHAMAS Crisis Centre Director Dr Sandra Dean-Patterson is not surprised by the conclusions of a new College of the Bahamas study showing that 58 per cent of high school boys in a recent survey believe men should discipline their female partners.

The study also revealed that 49 per cent of boys surveyed believe women should ask permission from their male partners if they want to go out while 46 per cent of boys believed wives must have sex when her husband wants to.

Many have expressed shock and concern about the findings since The Tribune reported on the study, which is in the latest edition of the International Journal of Bahamian Studies.

However, Dr Patterson said the study’s results are in line with her expectations, adding that they reflect this culture’s belief system.

“Our culture condones men and boys being in control in their relationships,” she said. “The man is to be the leader, the man is to be the head and women are to be passive. If you see the reaction we’re getting to changes in the Constitution as it relates to gender then the results shouldn’t be surprising. It’s just the whole patriarchy thing, a message that has gone to women throughout the centuries. Up until the earlier part of the 20th Century it was even okay for men to beat women so long as the instrument used to beat her was no thicker than the thumb. There’s a history as to why domestic violence has been so accepted.”

Dr Patterson emphasised that young people should not be blamed or criticised for their “regressive” views, as they reflect the views of society more generally.

“That blame game doesn’t work,” she said. “These students are reflecting what they learn, what they’re living with and whatever they’re thinking is coming from us.”

She added: “I always see these opportunities as teachable moments for us to talk to people in the community about the messages we are giving. It’s an opportunity to continue to dialogue. Power in violence and sexual assault comes from denial, shame, blame and victimisation. Only when you name the behaviours that are toxic can you get to make a difference.”

One thousand students from grades 10 to 12 from eight schools, including one private school, participated in COB’s study which was conducted by members of the Crisis Centre and COB’s academic community.

The study was an investigation into teen perspectives on relationships between the sexes and the prevalence of violence within teen relationships.

The study concluded that a large number of teens can be expected to be victims of controlling behaviour.

It added that modifying the attitudes of children with regard to interpersonal relationships may be important in reducing long-term violence in the country.

Amid questions about the credibility of the study, Dr Patterson said yesterday: “The fact that we had over 1,000 people responding gives us inferences we could draw on as to the thinking of children.

“The fact is the tolerance we have towards violence is reflected in the answers a lot of children gave.”

To help enforce key ideas in young people, the Bahamas Crisis Centre has taken its education campaign into high schools throughout the country.

However, Dr Patterson noted that conducting an awareness campaign for adults is equally as important.

“This is an opportunity for us to talk about what it means to be a man,” she added. “What are the qualities you would want to see in a man or a woman?”

Comments

John 9 years, 6 months ago

It would interesting to find who are the many who express shock and concern about men taking control of and disciplining their wives or female spouses. In all parts of the animal kingdom where there is a relationship between two creatures one takes control and in most instances it is the male. There are no mammals where the male does not take control offering guidence and protection to his mate and offspring. Even in gay and lesbian relationships one partner takes control of the other and it is usually the one playing the role of the "man". In fact in lesbian relationships it is reported that butch lesbians are more controlling and disciplining than regular males in a hetrosexual relationship.

0

UserOne 9 years, 6 months ago

Seriously?!?! You think your ridiculous arguments can be used to justify a misogynist society? One of the most offensive posts I have seen.

0

g945 9 years, 6 months ago

Men and Women are equal, sorry sir. What a misogynist pig! If the poor countrymen and women of the Bahamas were more education, there would be more liberation of women. Women need to assert themselves in this country. Your use of other mammals as an example to support patriarchy is ridiculous. Some mammals are cannabilistic, so does that entitle us to do the same? Many mammals practice homosexual behaviours, so it shouldn't be deemed as wrong by your logic, huh? The Bahamas is so far behind...

signed, a student away studying sociology and psychology.

0

virtualgina 9 years, 6 months ago

The biggest contributor to this attitude is that although the Bahamas is a matriarchal society (as far as who is "in charge" of the upbringing of our children, it is the women who treat boys differently in a way that suggests they are superior than their female counterparts. The way they cater to their sons and accept the irresponsible behaviour many exhibit makes it quite understandable that these students have the mentality they do. Women continue to be our own worse advocates and supporters and until we stop the ish and raise our sons to be respectful of ALL people, treat them with the same level of expectation and admonition as we do our daughters, then hold them accountable for their actions, we will have more of the same.

0

Sign in to comment