POLITICOLE: The real problem that Bahamians have with illegal Haitian immigrants


THE story of the Bahamian national of Haitian parentage who lost his illegal home in a legal demolition has made its way across every form of local media, perhaps most of all social media, where people have dialogued on the verge of meltdown.

As the Anson Aly threat grew more newsworthy in the Bahamas, in Canada a Canadian national shot and killed a Canadian soldier on duty and then stormed into the Canadian parliament to see who else he could take out; he was subsequently identified as a “terrorist” by the Canadian prime minister.

The terrorist’s motive was said to have been vengeance, having been a suspected militant and repeatedly denied a passport for travel to the Middle East. According to his mother, “he was mad and felt trapped so the only way out was death.”

Some Bahamians have called Aly a terrorist, which, per definition, is someone who threatens people with the intention of intimidating a society or government. Using this definition, the only real difference between the Canadian terrorist and the angry Haitian Bahamian is the fact that the latter wasn’t carrying a weapon when he made his threat.

Many Bahamians are concerned that if we take for a joke now threats of this nature, which approximate the definition of terrorist activity, who will be able to take such threats seriously or be themselves taken seriously later on? And where and when do you draw the line?

We’ve habitually allowed the little things that ail our nation to fall through the cracks, and we continue to do it, so we continue to suffer many a social ill.

On this issue, people are saying forgiveness is key. And, yes, I agree you can and should forgive. But forgiveness doesn’t exempt a wrongdoer from punishment. How many people in Fox Hill Prison are forgiven, yet they remain incarcerated?

In any other sensible, progressive country, our man Aly would have been made to incur some consequence greater than an apology for his threatening verbiage.

Only in this jokey little country can we not recognise a problem while it’s brewing. Maybe if we throw some political colours in the mix some people who need to jump would jump faster.

Many – including immigration minister Mitchell – are saying that Aly is just one person, and we should not allow one person to cause us alarm. But, to draw an analogy in the context of this subject, there was one person at the start of our problem with illegal immigrants, too. Look how that turned out.

I think the general idea amongst a large number of Bahamians is that it may be one person now, but who’s to say that the next “one person” won’t push the envelope further the next time, now that it is already clear how far threats can go unpunished and how silly we are in managing national security issues with no real demonstration of authority?

Our reality, whether you believe it, is that the one man, the one person, is representing countless others with the same mindset. And if you put Aly, or any other woman or man like him, in that situation again, or another situation like it, you’ll see where their allegiance really lies.

There is a very large group of compassionate people – of which I confess I am one – who understand the plight of immigrants to seek a better economic life in a country they think is prosperous. Hell, if the Bahamas is overrun by poor illegal immigrants or rich legal immigrants, many of us might find ourselves on a voyage to some other country we also believe to be prosperous, where we can seek a better quality of life all around.

But since Aly threatened his fellow Bahamians in a heated moment, there’s been a lot of dialogue about how unloving Bahamians are towards Haitians or people of Haitian descent. I won’t say that some Bahamians aren’t downright cruel, using “Haitian” as a derogatory word to describe someone unattractive, dark-skinned, broad-nosed, poor, colourfully dressed, with a high body odour. These are all hateful, hurtful things that would cause anyone to feel unhuman or marginalised. But this is not the real issue at hand.

The issue in this Aly incident is the specific underlying, ongoing problem Bahamians have with illegal Haitian immigrants and the inability or the refusal of our government and the Haitian government to stem the illegal influx of Haitian migrants to the Bahamas once and for all.

Minister Mitchell has been keen to point out that there is “not one international group” causing us problems with illegal immigration, but the fact of the matter is we all know where the biggest problem lies with respect to illegal immigration in the Bahamas – we can see it everywhere we turn. Yet the discussion somehow has centred on the statement that not only Haitians are a problem for us, but so are many other illegal populations.

Some have even likened the immigration plight of the Haitians in the Bahamas to the Mexicans in America. They ask why Bahamians are prejudiced against Haitians when we have other illegals to contend with. That we do. But there are a few significant differences between them, and I believe these differences are at the core of the anger and frustration that Bahamians have towards illegal Haitian migrants to the Bahamas.

Having lived in the Bahamas and America, and being exposed to both groups and their respective ways of life, I find that the problem many Bahamians have with illegal Haitian immigrants is a deep-seated frustration that goes far beyond their desire for a better life; no one wants to deny them that in principle. But illegal immigration of Haitians to the Bahamas is really a multi-pronged problem, and it is very similar in composition to the concerns US citizens have about illegal Mexican immigrants. And they are all legitimate concerns.

In my estimation, it comes down to three things, best explained by drawing comparisons to other large migrating populations, particularly of Chinese and Indian origin, as they are two of the largest in the world.

Within the Haitian and Mexican populations, there is often:

1) Violent aggression as a trademark of conflict management;

2) Low levels of education/ intellectual achievement prior to migration; and

3) Prolific reproductive lifestyles.

Firstly, by and large, as compared to the Haitian and Mexican immigrant populations, Chinese and Indian immigrants tend to have a higher degree of education before they migrate. Many have credentials for marketable skills beyond that of agricultural farmhands, and whereas the latter are necessary, the former present a diversity that is needed to build a country. Moreover, the (Indo) Asian immigrants have a better attitude about building a nation, which shows in the quality of their contribution to their host country.

They don’t continue to profess that their country of birth is better, or best, yet remain in the country they migrated to, taking everything they can, investing in nothing and repatriating their income or sharing it primarily within their own communities.

Secondly, Chinese and Indian immigrants tend not to breed by the half-dozen; not so for Haitian and Mexican immigrants. And this strikes a delicate and particular chord for me and many of my compatriots, because, in our younger years, we held off on reproducing to be responsible and to ensure that we were financially equipped to care for our children in the best way possible when we did have them, while the illegal Haitian immigrants multiplied and are still now procreating left and right with no care whatsoever for the burden it places on the Bahamian society.

Haitians and Mexicans are largely comprised of people who follow the Catholic religion, and they don’t readily subscribe to birth control. But when has “more mouths to feed” ever helped anybody’s economic situation or lifted them out of poverty? Clearly, there is something here that the Catholic church has failed to teach its followers: if you’re already in poverty, and you have little to no education to improve your opportunities, it tends to lead to greater poverty when you multiply inordinately.

Observing the growing numbers of illegal Haitian immigrants and their offspring in the Bahamas, it has become more than obvious that extreme/excessive reproduction is their way of life, and it is more likely to occur amongst the poorer Haitian and Mexican immigrant populations than the poor Chinese or Indian immigrants.

Finally, and without mincing words, Haitian and Mexican immigrants have a known culture of violent aggression, as demonstrated by the types of crimes they commit and the ways in which they commit them.

Chinese and Indian immigrants can be very pushy, maybe because they compete to survive in their very large populations, but their first idea to resolve a dispute isn’t to pop off 10 rounds on someone, beat them to a pulp, hack them to pieces, or tie them with a Colombian necktie. There’s a degree of responsibility in Chinese and Indian culture that makes them point their aggression at themselves.

I’m reminded of my Haitian neighbour who, only a few months ago, killed a baby bird on her porch with her slipper, when the little bird had only lost its way from its nest. The woman didn’t kill it because she was hungry and needed to eat it; she killed it just because it was there. And then threw it into the street.

It’s a simple, solitary incident, but it is still violent aggression for no reason whatsoever. All these isolated occurrences taken together reveal a strong tendency toward violence that lends itself to a colossal crime problem. And we have the numbers to prove it.

The reality is that extremely populated countries of the world have people who migrate to other nations in search of better lives for themselves and their children.

The countries they tend to migrate to are usually larger, developed countries, which have open job markets, the need for unskilled labourers, wide expanses of land to accommodate increases in population, and education and healthcare systems that are properly constructed and fairly well-operated and funded.

But what, of these things, do we have in our little Bahamas?

Is it not in the Bahamian interest to defend what little we do have, and insist that it be developed in a sustainable way?

To top it all off, when there is already a sizeable portion of the native Bahamian population that exhibits violent aggression, low education and high reproductivity, adding illegal immigrants of similar profiles only makes matters worse, because the Bahamian disadvantaged become even more marginalised in their own country.

But rather than impose a penalty on and make an example of the offender who threatens the little Bahamians have now, the authorities prefer to admonish the law-abiding. Their answer is for the people who are “up in arms” to “shoosh”. Be quiet. Stop talking about it. Don’t get upset. Move on.

Well, no. Because the path to being or becoming “ignorant” is to “ignore”, and to make no statement or movement with respect to the problem at hand.

And, if we don’t mind believing the genius Einstein, whose many theories about our world ring true to this day, “nothing happens until something moves.”

Give comments and suggestions at Tribune242.com, Facebook.com/politiCole, politiCole.com, or nicole@politiCole.com.


DEDDIE 9 years, 5 months ago

For the sake of disclosure I have been label a "Haitian sympathizer". Your article suggested that within the Haitian/Mexican population that violent aggression is the trademark of conflict resolution. How do you account for the fact that a recent United Nations surveys shows that the homicide rate in Haiti double between 2007 to 2012 to a total of 10.2 per 100,000.If you do the maths our beloved Bahamas has four time the homicide rate of Haiti. In fact, Haiti has one of the lowest homicide rates per 100,000 people in this region. Another fact, despite making up the largest group at the detention center, how many times a riot at the detention center can be attributed to Haitians. Also with regards to Mexicans immigrants, it is simply Karma in play. 1/3 of the United States is actually Mexico. Check the history with regards to the American/Mexico War. In concluding, no need to say, if Haiti is so safe why don't you go and live there. I am living here because I don't want to be an illegal immigrant in Haiti. I bet you don't have the nerve to write that crime and homicide is more prevalent among Negroes.


JohnDo 9 years, 5 months ago

@DEDDIE I would like for you to list your source, that crime and homicide is more prevalent among Negroes. I would also suggest in doing so that you look at the population of Negroes in the country you are speaking in regards to other races.


afficianado 9 years, 5 months ago

I wholeheartedly agree with this article. Maybe you should send this to Minister Mitchell.


DEDDIE 9 years, 5 months ago

The source is The United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime(https://www.unodc.org/gsh/en/big-pict...">https://www.unodc.org/gsh/en/big-pict...) They have quite a bit of data. Five of the ten countries with the highest homicide rate are predominantly black countries. Although there is a socioeconomic variable involve but despite the poverty levels in some pockets of Asia they don't have the same levels of crimes. We don't even need to go that far, how many times do you see a young white man before our courts. Base on our population there should be 1.5 whites for every 8.5 blacks in jail. Most whites in the Bahamas knows this but like the writer don't have the nerve to articulate it. She prefer the easy picking. a minority grouping.


DEDDIE 9 years, 5 months ago

The source is The United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime(https://www.unodc.org/gsh/en/big-pict...">https://www.unodc.org/gsh/en/big-pict...) Other sources,Haiti is actually safer than many of its Caribbean cousins. Haiti’s 2011 murder rate was 6.9 per 100,000 residents, compared to neighbouring Dominican Republic’s 24.9 and Jamaica’s 40.9.http://www.bbc.com/travel/blog/201301...">http://www.bbc.com/travel/blog/201301.... The Bahamas during the same year was 36 per 100,000 people.


Emac 9 years, 5 months ago

@DEDDIE: Bring all the data you can print about crime rate comparisons between countries. Draw as much conclusions as you like about people picking on a minority group. Present all the research you can compile on the habits of whites, blacks, brown and chocolate and their involvement in crimes. The fact of the matter is that the problem we have on hand has nothing to do with any of this.

The crux of the matter is that Anson Aly made a threat on national news and nothing happened. Since we are comparing other countries, you tell me which other country would allow any of its citizen, no matter what their status is, to make such a vile threat without any repercussion? None! All the writer is saying is that this situation has reached a boiling point and If we let this matter continue to go uncheck, it will be impossible to resolve in an orderly fashion. Once the horse is out the gate, that's it! I have witnessed first hand the problems that has come from the illegal Haitians and the Shanty towns.

No one is saying to be inhumane about resolving the matter. We are demanding that the powers that be make some real effort to bring change. The good minister of immigration is simply out of touch with what is really going on in this country. This man is not passionate about the Bahamas. He is passionate about his position and all the perks that come with it. When we pull our head out of the sand and really look at this situation then we will see the real danger we are facing.


DEDDIE 9 years, 5 months ago

Emac, I don't have a problem with her premise but I do have a problem with what she is using to support it. There is always the tendency to cite Mexican immigration without looking at the broader historic perspective. The average person is not aware that when the United States annex Texas, New Mexico and California, it also annexed Mexicans families living in those areas. I simply look at Mexicans moving to the US as them reclaiming what belongs to them.


duppyVAT 9 years, 5 months ago

The Haitians evolved from a violent, oppressive slave society that revolted against the French using Voodoo, poison and machetes. The Bahamas did not evolve in that way. Thats the difference between our peoples.


DEDDIE 9 years, 5 months ago

At one point I thought it was pretty sad that Bahamian slave accepted slavery laying down until a research I did showed otherwise. The Abaco slaves rebel in 1787 and the Rolle slave under Pompey rebel on three separate occasion, 1829, 1833, 1834. In fact one of the major reason why slavery ended was because the slave master was made aware that the negro desired Freedom as much as he did, even to the point of killing for it. All this time, I bet you thought it was the abolitionist who was responsible for the Negros' freedom. Fear was the motivating factor that what happened in Haiti can happen anywhere.


duppyVAT 9 years, 5 months ago

Emac please think for yourself............ Bahamian blacks never thought of their blackness like Haitian or American slaves...... thats why we are unique in our outlook at racial stereotypes ... think James Weldon Johnson, Robert Love and Sidney Poitier to name a few ....... we are a proud, independent and progressive bunch of black people........ but our leaders are Oreos.


DEDDIE 9 years, 5 months ago

Its amazing you mentioned Sidney Poitier whose ancestors was from Haiti. So are the Moncurs, Deleveaux, Deveaux, Mitchels and the list goes on. Its amazing that some of the propaganda of the plantation endures today. Bahamian slaves were told that they were from a different breed of Africans(a peaceful tribe)to keep then subdued. The generational slaves believe it but the recent arrivals knew different. They knew that their blood relatives was spread all over the New World including Haiti. Stop spewing plantation propaganda.


ThisIsOurs 9 years, 5 months ago

I'm still stuck on "killed a baby bird with her slipper"


Sign in to comment