Gbhra President Accuses Mitchell Of ‘Fear Tactics’

Fred Smith and Fred Mitchell.

Fred Smith and Fred Mitchell.


Tribune Chief Reporter



THE Grand Bahama Human Rights Association yesterday accused Foreign Affairs and Immigration Minister Fred Mitchell

of using “fear tactics” to stifle free speech in the country.

GBHRA President Fred Smith underscored a “disturbing trend” in Mr Mitchell’s recent public statements in response to comments that were “potentially critical” of himself, the government, or the Progressive Liberal Party.

Mr Smith said: “In an approach familiar to anyone who has lived under an authoritarian dictatorship where individual rights and freedoms are trampled upon by those in power, Mitchell has taken to branding any utterance he objects to a ‘national security’ concern, or some other form of serious threat, then seeking to have law enforcement investigate whomever he feels has offended him.

“We saw this recently with his revelation that Baha Mar developer Sarkis Izmirlian is ‘under investigation’ in relation to some mysterious complaints about his ‘conduct in the country,’” he said.

“Ominously vague allegations followed by the threat of official action – here we have the classic dynamic by which, throughout history, tyrants have sought to terrify members of the public into silence.”

Mr Smith pointed to accusations levelled by Mr Mitchell at the GBHRA due to its opposition to the government’s new immigration policy.

At that time, Mr Mitchell suggested that the actions of GBHRA and other activists were possibly aiding human smugglers.


Mr Mitchell also accused Mr Smith of making inflammatory comments against the Christie administration on a local radio show following the implementation of the new policy on November 16.

The show, the Kreyol Konnection, was reported to regulator URCA and subsequently cancelled.

Mr Smith added: “Mitchell’s fear tactics were on display yet again this week, in his reaction to a town hall meeting organised by Haitian-Bahamian community group, The Connection.

“In his shadowy, provocative reference to the involvement of ‘certain activists’ and his claim that some undisclosed ‘unfortunate things’ were said, the minister clearly sought to paint in a sinister light an event that was completely above board and conducted in the spirit of community and open information sharing.”

Mr Smith said that the chairmen of the PLP and FNM were invited to attend the event.

“There was nothing whatsoever about the meeting that could be construed as clandestine or tending towards incitement,” he said.

“But it was apparently necessary for Mitchell to paint the event in such a light, in order to justify his claim it should be examined ‘by the national security people’ – textbook thug tactics for silencing free speech.”

Mr Smith added: “The GBHRA, along with all other defenders of the Constitution, will continue to advocate for the greater recognition of the rights and protections enshrined therein through open discussion, advocacy, and legal action if necessary. We will not be intimidated by base threats and petty sabre rattling.”


Emac 5 years, 2 months ago

So the white ghost can actually speak out against other issues besides illegal immigrants, hmmm. BTW, It seems Smith has a thing for Mitchell, because he only comes out of his shell when Mitchell has something to say. I guess child abuse, oppression of the poor, and all of the ills that are rampant in our society are not important enough for the GBHRA to talk about.


Tarzan 5 years, 2 months ago

The issue Mr. Smith highlights in his commentary is no light matter. Mr. Mitchell is without question using the tactics of totalitarian governments to attempt to silence what heretofore was a right to free, unfettered political speech, in the Bahamas.

The facile attempts to step aside from this atrocious breach of faith with the Bahamian people by the Prime Minister, by simply saying such comments do not reflect government policy, is totally inadequate.

When a member of government with an important ministerial portfolio threatens citizens and residents left and right with police investigations and deportation, it does chill free speech.

Where does the PLP stand on this issue?????


Cas0072 5 years, 2 months ago

It takes one to know one. I am sure that that Fred Smith is equally aware of how his comments play on the minds,emotions, and actions of illegal immigrants and the impression that it may leave on the international community. If the comments did not cross the line, as some attendees have claimed, then there is no need for concern.


Wideawake 5 years, 2 months ago

Although Fred Smith sometimes does get carried away in his passionate defense of Human Rights and Freedom of Speech, he nevertheless plays an essential and valuable role as one of our national watchdogs regarding the civil rights of all Bahamians, especially the most weak and vulnerable in our society. Keep up the good work, Fred Smith!


TruePeople 5 years, 2 months ago

It's a blessing that someone have balls enough to take a public stand against freddy boy stupidness. If that turn into almost a full time job for Mr. Smith it just showing you how much an issue Mitchell really is


birdiestrachan 5 years, 2 months ago

Fred Smith could not care less about the civil rights of Bahamians. Fred is all about starting a Haitian party in the Bahamas. He said so on Georges ,Have you ever heard him speak up for any Bahamian , Bahamian, only Haitian Bahamians.


Sign in to comment