Bethel: Minister’S Comments Fly In The Face Of Decency


Attorney Marion Bethel.


Tribune Staff Reporter


SOCIAL Services Minister Lanisha Rolle’s comments on marital rape “flies in the face of commonsense and human decency” and she needs to be more “informed and aware” of the issues she speaks about before speaking “utter nonsense,” according to attorney and United Nations expert Marion Bethel.

In an interview with The Tribune, Mrs Bethel, who was elected to serve on the United Nations Committee on the Elimination of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW), said she is extremely disappointed that Mrs Rolle, the only woman in Cabinet, would not take a firm stance on the issue of marital rape.

She also criticised Prime Minister Dr Hubert Minnis for refusing to express his personal views on the matter saying: “It is ridiculous that he chooses to remain silent” on the subject.

On Tuesday, Mrs Rolle told reporters marital rape was a “private” matter that could become public and shied away from taking a firm position on whether it should be outlawed. Instead she insisted marriage is private and its sanctity should be protected.

Mrs Rolle said before the government acts or makes determinations that legislate how people’s personal lives are managed – adding there are two sides to every story – there should be a proper national conversation on spousal rape. Once a public consensus is taken, she said the Minnis administration should act accordingly.

“To Minister Rolle, the issue of marital rape is not a private issue, rape is a criminal offence and marital rape ought to be a criminal offence,” Mrs Bethel said. “Forcing someone within a marriage erodes the sacredness and ought to be a punishable offence.

“Her comments were utter nonsense and ridiculous and just flies in the face of commonsense and human decency. It is a violation of woman and needs to be criminalised. There is no way in 2017 there should not be that kind of protection for women. As minister of social services she has a responsibility to be aware and more informed on this issue. Her ministry is where the issue needs to have leadership and guidance and help shape public opinion. I am just really disappointed, she is not well informed and clearly does not understand that rape is not about sex, but it is about power. It is a violation and it is not a matter of consensual sex, which is a private issue.”

Mrs Bethel said the Bahamas has signed on to several human rights treaties and has an obligation to comply and with international obligations. She said in October 2018, she will have to make a national report on the status of women before CEDAW and now “I have to go and say once again, that we have not done anything.”

She called on Dr Minnis to make his views on marital rape public and to lead the issue rather than “letting the public decide.”

“The prime minister ought to have personal views and he needs to express his views on the matter and make them transparent to the public,” she said.

“He is the leader and he needs to give leadership and guidance on the marital rape law. I am disappointed that he said he didn’t have a personal view. It is his voice that we need to hear from at this time.”

Mrs Bethel applauded Deputy Prime Minister K Peter Turnquest, State Minister for Legal Affairs Elsworth Johnson and former Transport and Aviation Minister Glenys Hanna Martin for their support of criminalising marital rape.

On Monday, Attorney General Carl Bethel, acknowledging the controversial nature of the issue, said he hopes a compromise can be made resulting in characterising sex without consent in a marriage as sexual spousal abuse as opposed to rape. This, he said, could be addressed by amending the Matrimonial Causes Act or the Domestic Violence (Protection Orders) Act.


John 1 year, 8 months ago

So what is Marion Bethel ‘s husband’s last name again ‘ OR just in case you forget!


Maynergy 1 year, 8 months ago

P. Carl Gibson - Home | Facebook https://www.facebook.com/BehindGreyCu...">https://www.facebook.com/BehindGreyCu... Rating: 4 - ‎1 vote P. Carl Gibson. 35 likes. Behind Grey Curtains" by P. Carl Gibson, could very well as of the May 10th, 2017, show how generations of people rejected.

http://tribune242.com/users/photos/20...">http://thetribune.media.clients.ellin..." alt="None">

by Maynergy


sheeprunner12 1 year, 8 months ago

Marion Bethel is not representative of the average Bahamian married woman .......... she refuses to take the last name of her husband and he is bi-sexual ......... So how can she speak for normal married Bahamian women????


Islangal1 1 year, 8 months ago

And what does that have to do with the price of tea in China? Her personal life has absolutely nothing to do with the issue of Marital Rape!!


ohdrap4 1 year, 8 months ago

it just shows who sheeprunner really is.

so scared of woman.

but not to worry, woman cannot birth little bahamians so the males will have to marry between themselves.


sheeprunner12 1 year, 7 months ago

Who the messenger is says a lot about the motives behind the message...... and FYI, the sheeprunner is not homophobic nor misogynistic ....... just a straight-up God-fearing person with a high moral character and who believes in traditional Christian family values ......... and you?????


TorontoGal 1 year, 8 months ago

It doesn't matter if a wife does not take her husband's name nor whether her husband "might be bi-sexual". What does matter is whether you are married or not rape is rape! A wife is not a piece of property or a second class citizen. She is a woman who has every right to say no should she want to.

Who would want to have sex with someone who hasn't bathed in a week and stinks of booze. No one regardless if married to the drunken slob or not. Just because the husband in horny isn't a reason to demand sex.

When men realize that rape is not sex but the power over someone will they understand about marital rape! Grow up Bahama men and get some education on the subject.

Please don't bring the Bible into this. The Lord gave each of us a brain to use....so use it!


tetelestai 1 year, 8 months ago

Thank you Torontogal. The scatological thinking of John and sheeprunner is unfortunately prevalent in todays society. This issue is not a referendum on Marion Bethel, but rather, on whethr rape is rape. At least "sheep"runner is true to his name.


sheeprunner12 1 year, 7 months ago

This is a classic case of a minor issue being blown up by liberal feminists ...... are we going down the road of Blue USA, Canada, Europe and Australia?????

We are not that type of white society ...... Why pretend to be what we are not????? Everyone keep saying that so many Bahamian women are physically and sexually abused by their male partners (stats please?) ......... but how many of the same-sex partner murders have been solved in The Bahamas??? ......... Will Marion and her merry girls (like Torontogal) comment on that???


Sign in to comment