Wrong e-mail caused blacklisting by France

Attorney General Carl Bethel. (File photo)

Attorney General Carl Bethel. (File photo)

* AG: Tax info requests went to incorrect address

* Promises that 'all concerns were addressed'

* Bahamas beefing-up 'profile' within Europe


Tribune Business Editor


The Bahamas was blacklisted by France because of an incorrect e-mail address, the attorney general has revealed to Tribune Business.

Carl Bethel QC disclosed that French requests for information on the tax affairs of its citizens and companies had not been answered by The Bahamas because they were being sent to an e-mail address that was not being monitored by the Ministry of Finance.

He added that once the problem was identified The Bahamas moved rapidly to address it, ensuring that French tax information exchange requests made under the Organisation for Economic Co-Operation and Development's (OECD) common reporting standard (CRS) and other applicable treaties were responded to appropriately and within the required time.

While France has yet to publicly confirm that The Bahamas has satisfied its concerns, and removed this nation from its so-called national "blacklist", Mr Bethel said he was confident "we have addressed the issues" that caused the problem to arise. He did not say who was responsible for the wrong address, or how many requests were involved.

"The French CRS requests for information were not getting through to us. We've found out what the problem was and addressed all their concerns," he told this newspaper. "The French had justifiable concerns.

"Once we did an investigation we found there was a gap in our system where they were sending [the information requests] to one e-mail address that nobody looked at. Once we identified where they were sending it we found them, and the Ministry of Finance addressed every last once."

France's decision to "blacklist" The Bahamas in December 2019 was greeted with outrage by the Government and its ministers. K Peter Turnquest, former deputy prime minister and minister of finance, slammed the move as "devious" as he voiced his "total disgust" at the action.

Slamming the "surreptitious" decision as "an affront" to international diplomatic norms, and the relationship this nation had sought to build with France, Mr Turnquest said then that The Bahamas' inclusion among countries deemed non-cooperative in the fight against tax-related crimes stemmed from "the perception by the French authorities" that this nation "has not been responding to requests for information in a manner that is satisfactory to them"

He added that an inter-governmental investigation at the time had not turned up any French tax information requests that remained outstanding or had not been dealt with, saying The Bahamas has "nothing on the record".

And Mr Turnquest voiced particular displeasure at the French action given that it was a member of two bodies that deemed The Bahamas compliant with their various tax demands - the European Union (EU) and OECD.

He also criticised France's failure to invoke the dispute resolution process contained in the Multilateral Convention on Mutual Assistance in Tax Matters, which The Bahamas signed in late 2017 to facilitate tax information exchange and co-operation.

Mr Bethel, meanwhile, told Tribune Business in a recent interview that the French "blacklisting" showed that "The Bahamas has to heighten its profile" - especially among individual member states of the 27-strong EU.

With The Bahamas now removed from the Financial Action Task Force's (FATF) enhanced scrutiny, Mr Bethel said the Government was already switching its focus to securing The Bahamas' removal from the EU's "blacklist" and improving bilateral relations with its members.

"Our focus has already switched in some ways," he confirmed. "We've already started to shift our focus. We've had a series of phone calls with key EU countries - Italy, Germany, Hungary, Slovenia, Finland and Cyprus so far.

"We're not expecting member states to override the EU Commission, but part of the outreach is to show we're seeking to develop strong bilateral state-to-state connections with The Bahamas. To avoid further instances [of blacklisting[ with other countries that may not have the relationship with us like the French, we're looking to build direct bilateral relationships at the technical level."

This, Mr Bethel said, would enable The Bahamas to respond rapidly and potentially head-off any regulatory or other developments that could be damaging to the financial services industry.

"If you don't know the country, any propaganda against it is as good as true," he added. "The idea is to craft other bilateral relationships state-by-state because if something arises and you don't know the country, that can be as good as true. The Bahamas has to heighten its profile."

The attorney general added that The Bahamas has already responded to the EU's "well-founded concerns" by reforming its Register of Beneficial Ownership Act to meet the demands of a powerful nation bloc's whose anti-financial crime standards are "FATF-plus" and above the global norm.

"We had to tighten it up because the concerns were valid," he added of the Act. "We had to block of the issue of companies who did not have registered agents, as only the latter were originally required to provide beneficial ownership information. The compliance unit is dealing with that, and moving to drive compliance on behalf of companies without registered agents.'

Mr Bethel continued: "We are simply seeking our living space, and we don't want to have our living space at the expense of any other jurisdiction. Within that broad parameter we feel there is more than adequate space for the Bahamas to have a financial services sector that's in compliance with current and emerging global financial standards."


Sickened 3 years, 4 months ago

People need to start picking up the phone if they are not getting a response. Don't keep sending the same follow-up to the same address if you are not getting a response.


GodSpeed 3 years, 4 months ago

Dummies in government who don't even know how to check an email address and send a read receipt.


ohdrap4 3 years, 4 months ago

Lol. Folks who also hit reply to all.

And also cannot print pdf. Lol.

They do not even realise how stupid they sound.


Craig 3 years, 4 months ago

The responsible party is probably a PLP trying to make the FNM look bad. Unless people are held accountable for such a screw up the public service will never improve.


TalRussell 3 years, 4 months ago

The irony tis true, 'tis pity - combine this with the same bunch of redshirts colleagues put in charge of educating our students online? Even my Grandma Lucy Mae can check her emails Shakehead a quick once for upyeahvote nothing more shadows Jeff Lloyd's exam results in nonsense. Shake twice for not?


bahamianson 3 years, 4 months ago

Stop Whats Apping while working , that's all you need to do. This is an inacceptable excuse. The country gets blacklisted because I had to use the bathroom. Banana Republic.


The_Oracle 3 years, 4 months ago

Wonder what else is in that 86 file inbox to nowhere? No matter, declare war, France surrenders, all is well again.


ThisIsOurs 3 years, 4 months ago

I can almost believe it was Simon Wilson's email account.... or something of that nature. An account that someone should have been monitoring or had emails forwarded from but nobody did. This happens often and even though its easily explainable, when it happens it's a failure. I'm not sure what investigation they had to do..as soon as the people said "we sent an email", the next question should have been "to who? forward that to me".

I wish we could have a govt that gives us the explanation, but accepts fault when things break. When things go well the minister always points to himself when they go bad they point fingers at the pluck up working in the corner office. Like Mr Lloyd just accept that the results were bad and measure what "bad" is, 40,50,60% of the mark that we expected, identify what fell through, tell us, then tell us how it will be fixed.


BONEFISH 3 years, 4 months ago

This government removed Wilson from his post several years ago. Why would e-mails still be sent to his account? It should have been disabled.

I notice you have something against Wilson. Any lie or mistruth against him ,you are quick to repeat in this forum.

According to the late Sir William Allen, Wilson was a very competent civil servant when he worked with him Also can you can enlighten me on the reason the acting financial secretary left his post at BTC.


tribanon 3 years, 4 months ago

Sorry Bethel, but I'm just not that gullible. LOL


Sign in to comment