![]()
Come on, Rollins, you’re not fooling anyone. Your claims to be a loyal lieutenant to FNM leader Michael Pintard may be true – to a degree. But “no space” between the two of you? Come on, Rollins. Nobody is buying that.
It is hardly a secret that you want to be the FNM’s main man. And almost everyone, it seems, apart from the current main man, recognises that the party desperately needs a new leader - man or woman.
Pintard is a decent, honest man. But his time at the helm should surely be coming to an end. He has had his opportunity to lead the FNM to victory and failed. Badly. There is little reason to believe another attempt will produce a different result.
Some senior party figures complain that he repeatedly refused to listen during the run-up to the May election. They fear he is making the same mistake now. If he were listening to the mood within his party, he might think twice about entering a leadership contest in which his chances appear increasingly slim. There is a case for stepping aside gracefully. There remains a place for him at the table, but not at the top.
The findings presented by Jamaican political consultants brought in to examine the FNM’s election defeat make uncomfortable reading. Their research found Pintard to be the least popular of the country’s three main party leaders and the one most frequently associated with being “petty”. “Petty Pintard” is how some describe him in political circles. Fair or not, that is hardly a reputation for someone aspiring to become prime minister.
Pintard can point to his strong personal position in Grand Bahama, where he retained his Marco City seat. But the FNM’s combined vote across the island’s five constituencies was just 14 more than the PLP’s – 8,969 against 8,955. In New Providence, the picture was disastrous: the FNM won only three of the island’s 25 seats.
At the party’s recent conclave, Dr André Rollins, reportedly challenged the consultants’ description of Pintard as an electoral asset in Grand Bahama. Did that make him a liability in New Providence, where, according to research Rollins cited, only eight per cent of voters supported the party leader? He also questioned the consultants’ methodology and whether the party was being given a full explanation of why voters had deserted it.
Pintard has confirmed he intends to defend his leadership. But the FNM cannot afford to keep looking backwards when it needs to rebuild for the future.
It needs a new Hubert Ingraham: someone who can lead, inspire supporters, unite the ranks and communicate a clear sense of purpose. Someone who says what they mean and means what they say. But Papas don’t grow on trees.
Dr Rollins is certainly not the new Papa. But could the Honourable Member for Long Island help shape the FNM’s revival?
To understand the possibilities – and the reservations – it is worth looking at his political journey. Rollins is hardly a traditional FNM stalwart. In 2008, he helped establish the National Development Party with B J Moss and became its chairman. The movement emerged from frustration with the established parties and a belief that Bahamian politics needed a clearer national development vision.
He contested the 2010 Elizabeth by-election for the NDP, polling fewer than 100 votes. In 2011, he joined the PLP under Perry Christie, believing it was better placed to deliver change. He won Fort Charlotte in the 2012 general election.
But his relationship with the Christie administration soon soured. Rollins became one of its most outspoken internal critics, challenging policies including VAT, gambling legislation and the government’s handling of crime and electricity costs. His criticism brought disciplinary action and the loss of his chairmanship of the Gaming Board.
In June 2015, he resigned from the PLP and became an Independent MP, complaining of intolerance towards internal dissent. He initially ruled out an immediate move to the FNM. But five months later, he crossed the floor alongside Renward Wells, accusing the PLP of failing to deliver the change it had promised.
Even within the FNM, Rollins was no unquestioning loyalist. In December 2016, he was among seven FNM MPs who supported replacing Hubert Minnis as Opposition leader with Loretta Butler-Turner, exposing deep divisions within the party.
Now, having returned to Parliament as the FNM MP for Long Island, he is once again at the centre of the leadership debate. His political history shows a man prepared to challenge those at the top when he disagrees with their direction. That may be refreshing. It can also make him a difficult colleague.
A television interview with Rollins is due to air tonight on Our News’ On The Record, where he is expected to discuss recent controversies, his politics and his vision for the country. The timing is interesting. Whatever he says, the interview gives him another opportunity to set out his stall – and perhaps offer a glimpse of what an FNM under his influence might look like. A brief preview released last night showed he’s in the mood for a fight with the PLP and Fred Mitchell.
It’s also worth asking exactly who else is there to consider ahead of the party’s national convention, which will be held no later than April 30, 2027.
Rick Fox has indicated that he intends to seek an FNM leadership position, although he has not said which one. The former NBA superstar has an extraordinary international profile and declared a net worth of approximately $469 million in his election financial disclosure. But he failed to win Garden Hills in May. His entry into the leadership debate certainly raised eyebrows. There were audible gasps of “What?” when he made the announcement during a Senate debate. That reaction probably tells its own story.
Then there is deputy leader Shanendon Cartwright, who lost the newly created St James constituency in May after previously representing St Barnabas. He was subsequently overlooked when Pintard appointed four opposition senators, a decision that attracted criticism within the party.
Cartwright was noticeably quiet during much of the election campaign. Recently, however, he has become more vocal, regularly issuing statements and attacking the PLP. Is he positioning himself for a bigger role? Quite possibly. Whether he can command sufficient support among the party faithful is another matter.
Party chairman Dr Duane Sands remains an influential voice, but he too lost his seat, going down to Patricia Deveaux in Bamboo Town. His experience and standing within the FNM are not in question, but his electoral record will inevitably be part of any leadership discussion.
Kwasi Thompson, the East Grand Bahama MP and former finance minister, is another name mentioned in succession discussions. Widely seen as a talented, intelligent and popular politician, teaming up as deputy to Rollins could make for a formidable partnership. Watch this space.
Newly elected MPs Lincoln Deal and Michela Barnett-Ellis may have promising political futures, but it is too early for either to be considered a serious contender for the top job.
So, we return to “no space” Rollins.
He is quick-thinking, combative and sharp in the House of Assembly. He has also attracted plenty of attention from the PLP, with senior figures and party supporters taking aim at him on social media. Some of the attacks have been personal.
One particularly vocal account uses the name Abigail – or Abagail – Cartwright and claims a connection to Dean’s Blue Hole on Long Island. We would welcome the opportunity to hear directly from the person behind it. The account’s identity and the authenticity of its claims have not been independently established. Some of its posts have a formulaic quality, but that alone is no evidence that they were generated by artificial intelligence. It is the age of AI so ChatGPT was asked for its opinion. It agreed the words certainly sounded familiar.
The Long Island voters’ list was carefully checked but no one listed under either version of the name was found. That does not establish who is behind the account, or even whether the person is a Long Island resident. But it does raise a reasonable question: who is this person, and why are they so determined to attack Rollins? If Ms Cartwright is reading, we would be happy to hear from her.
Does Rollins have some people in the PLP rattled? It certainly looks that way. But the bigger question is whether he can turn the attention into something more substantial.
His political career has been marked by ambition, conviction and a willingness to break with party leaders. He has founded a political movement, represented the PLP, sat as an Independent and eventually joined the FNM. That makes him an unusual candidate for the party’s leadership. It also raises questions about his ability to build lasting alliances and bring people with him.
The disagreement with Pintard at the conclave reportedly continued at Lumpy’s bar that Saturday evening, where Rollins told the party leader he was considering challenging him and did not want any bad blood between them. Rollins subsequently played down suggestions of a rift, insisting there was “no space” between them.
Perhaps. But nobody should mistake public declarations of loyalty for an absence of ambition.
The FNM needs more than a new leader. It must confront why it lost so decisively, rebuild confidence among supporters and reconnect with voters, particularly in New Providence. Whoever takes charge will have a formidable task.
Dr Rollins may or may not be the answer. He is certainly no Hubert Ingraham. But he has put himself firmly into the conversation – and Michael Pintard would be unwise to underestimate him.
Mosquito



Comments
Use the comment form below to begin a discussion about this content.
Sign in to comment
OpenID